Berkeley CSUA MOTD:Entry 43445
Berkeley CSUA MOTD
 
WIKI | FAQ | Tech FAQ
http://csua.com/feed/
2025/07/09 [General] UID:1000 Activity:popular
7/9     

2006/6/20-24 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:43445 Activity:nil
6/20    I have an MSA20 (a scsi attached raid enclosure) from HP that uses
        SATA disks.  My company is somewhat cheap and I'd like to keep an extra
        disk on hand, but not pay for the nifty drive carrier.  (this way when
        a drive fails, I can just remove it, swap out the disk in the carrier
        and slap it back in without waiting for shipping).  BUT, when I tested
        this it didn't work.  The drives are the exact same model, but there is
        some HP specific printing on the label (and a 4 letter, comma separated
        code, which is different).  I have used dd to insure that the disks are
        have the same bits, but no joy, any of you know what it is that makes
        the HP disk different?  -crebbs
        \_ firmware
        \_ ah the joy of vendor lock-in
        \_ I'm not sure how using HP saves your company money.  There are tons
           of cheapy scsi attached raid boxes out there which will happily
           take any same sized disk to replace a bad drive.
           \_ HP isn't saving the company money.  The product needs to run
              on HP.
              \_ No reason to be tied to HP for storage.  Fine, buy HP for
                 the CPU, but detach CPU/computation from storage wrt vendors
                 \_ You buy HP for the support, and when you buy large, their
                    discounts are deep.  Also, doesn't apply to the MSA, but
                    their EVAs are pretty freakin cool.
                    \_ EVAs are likely way out of the price range for crebbs
                       company.  If they won't buy the right disks they won't
                       buy an EVA.  And yes they're pretty cool.  At least as
                       cool as storage can be, anyway.
                       \_ Why would I want an EVA instead of, say, a Netapp?
                          \_ There's nothing wrong with a Netapp, per se.  Its
                             just that the EVA is 'better'.  I like the EVA
                             architecture better.  Virtual-virtual disks
                             across the whole array with no hot spares doing
                             nothing, the control software is more mature
                             although it does run from a windows box.  In
                             general the EVA is just a more mature and serious
                             product than the Netapp.  I've used the Netapp
                             since before they were anyone.  The EVA is new to
                             me but I prefer it overall.  Of course the EVA
                             will cost a lot more in $/tb but there's a certain
                             amount of "get what you pay for" if you can afford
                             it.  What I don't like about the Netapp is the
                             very patchy way it has developed over time.  New
                             features get jacked in, some hardware level
                             maintenance requires on-site hands but really
                             shouldn't, half the tech problems can be handled
                             by shutting down all the shelves (via big red
                             switch) and powering back up *and not in any
                             other way*.  I wouldn't use Netapp for front line
                             real time 24/7 storage if I could afford better.
        \_ It may not be HP issue, but the drive manufacturer issue.  I've had
           numerous cases where the drives of identical model actually had
           slightly different size(usually by few thousand blocks.)  And if it
           turns out the new drive has smaller # of blocks than the rest of the
           drives, that may be why.
2025/07/09 [General] UID:1000 Activity:popular
7/9     

You may also be interested in these entries...
2013/5/6-18 [Transportation/Car, Computer/HW/Printer] UID:54673 Activity:nil
5/6     http://goo.gl/KiIMT (shortened link from http://HP.com)
        seems like I get these every 6 months or so from HP.  Do all drives
         have these kind of issues and I only see the ones from HP because
         they are diligent about reporting/fixing these issues?  Or do they
         suck?   (It's not actually their drives so...)  Also, do I really
         need to bring down my production infrastructure and fix all this
	...
2012/1/4-2/6 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:54281 Activity:nil
1/4     I want to test how my servers behave during a disk failure and
        a RAID reconstruction so I want to simulate a hardware failure.
        How can I do this in Linux without having to physically pull
        a drive? These disks are behind a RAID card and run Linux. -ausman
        \_ According to the Linux RAID wiki, you might be able to use mdadm
           to do this with something like the following:
	...
2011/9/14-10/25 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:54173 Activity:nil
9/13    Thanks to Jordan, our disk server is no longer virtualized. Our long
        nightmare of poor IO performance should hopefully be over. Prepare for
        another long nightmare of poor hardware reliability!
        ...
        Just kidding! (I hope)
        In any case, this means that cooler was taken out back and shot, and
	...
2011/2/14-4/20 [Computer/SW/Unix] UID:54039 Activity:nil
2/14    You sure soda isn't running windows in disguise?  It would explain the
        uptimes.
        \_ hardly, My winbox stays up longer.
        \_ Nobody cares about uptime anymore brother, that's what web2.0 has
           taught us.  Everything is "stateless".
           \_ You;d think gamers would care more about uptime.
	...
2011/2/18-4/20 [Computer/SW/Unix] UID:54044 Activity:nil
2/18    Why does the system seem so sluggish lately?
        \_ Slow NFS is basically always the answer. --toulouse
        \_ Any truth to the rumor that soda will be decommissioned this summer?
           \_ Absolutely none. Soda might go down temporarily while disks are
              reorganized and stuff so soda doesn't suffer from such shitty
              performance nearly as much, but no, we've gotta maintain NFS and
	...
2010/7/22-8/9 [Computer/SW/OS/FreeBSD, Computer/HW/Drives] UID:53893 Activity:nil
7/22    Playing with dd if=/dev/random of=/dev/<disk> on linux and bsd:
        2 questions, on linux when <disk>==hda it always gives me this off
        by one report i.e. Records out == records in-1 and says there is an
        error. Has anyone else seen this?  Second, when trying to repeat this
        on bsd, <disk>==rwd0 now, to my surprise, using the install disk and
        selecting (S)hell, when I try to dd a 40 gig disk it says "409 records
	...
2010/1/26-2/8 [Computer/HW/Memory] UID:53665 Activity:nil
1/26    What's a good motherboard I can get that will fit in a 1U
        case, with sata connectors, gig-e ethernet, and lots of
        slots for RAM?  I also don't want to have to use expensive
        double buffered RAM.  Can you tell I havne't bought a PC in
        years?  thanks.
        \_ Buy a mac. Haven't you heard? if you don't buy a Mac people
	...
2010/1/22-30 [Computer/HW/Laptop, Computer/SW/OS/OsX] UID:53655 Activity:high
1/22    looking to buy a new development laptop
        needs ssdrive, >6 hr possible batt life, and runs linux reasonably
        Anyone have a recommendation? Thx.
        \_ thinkpad t23 w ssdrive and battery inplace of drive bay
        \_ Ever wondered what RICHARD STALLMAN uses for a laptop?  Well,
           wonder no more!
	...