www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2009/01/31/BUM615JQNS.DTL
Comments Georgia (default) Verdana Times New Roman Arial Font | Size: Waiting to go condo is San Francisco's version of waiting for Godot. Building owners can spend years vying for one of 200 condo-conversion slots awarded annually via a lottery. But this year San Francisco is considering letting people skip the line, offering a one-time chance to the hundreds of folks on the lottery list to go condo now - for an extra fee. The goal is to generate more revenue for the cash-strapped city and to create building-industry jobs, because condo conversions generally require some construction work to bring buildings up to code.
A proposal to expedite condo conversion would require approval by either the supervisors or the voters - no easy task in a city where housing issues are famously contentious. Tenant advocates say the practice hurts renters who get evicted when buildings convert to tenancies in common, the step before going condo. Previous proposals for increased condo conversions have failed miserably. Supporters say the sour economy could change the dynamics this time around. "What's different this year is that the city is in such a financial hole, this is a way to help," said Mike Sullivan, board chair of Plan C San Francisco, a moderate civic organization that supports the idea. "If all the city did was grandfather in the 1,500 people waiting behind the lottery, just doing that would help the city's budget." Supervisor Sean Elsbernd, the proposal's instigator, said the extra fees would directly benefit affordable and supportive housing, as a way to remediate the plan's impact on the rental housing market. A total of 2,030 individual units are entered into this year's lottery, which takes place Friday. Also on that day, Plan C is organizing a demonstration at City Hall to protest the lengthy wait for condo conversion. The units converting to condos are tenancies in common, in which a group of people own a building together, as opposed to each family owning an individual condo unit. Condos are more valuable because of their separate ownership structure, and can more easily be sold or tapped for equity loans. Pricing for the one-time chance to convert is still up in the air. Currently, condo conversions cost a little less than $10,000, money that directly reimburses the city for the cost of inspections and other services. The controller's office is crunching numbers to determine what would be a reasonable fee, Elsbernd said. Ted Gullicksen, director of the San Francisco Tenants Union, said the proposal ultimately would hurt renters. "The easier we make it for tenancies in common to become condominiums, the more TICs will be created. The larger issue is that people are creating TICs to get around the condo conversion law" that provides more tenant protections. Miguel Wooding, executive director of the Eviction Defense Collaborative, agreed. "The condo conversion law has been around for a long time and has been an important protection for preserving rent-controlled housing stock," he said. A one-time mega conversion "sets up expectations of the possibility of increasing TIC conversions in the future. You have an increased motivation to increase evictions (to create TICs) if you have that possibility." But for TIC owners who've been cooling their heels in the lottery, the idea has a definite appeal. "Being strapped in a loan with other people is just very difficult," said Liz Johnson, a project manager at Kaiser Permanente who owns a TIC in a three-unit building in the Mission that's been in the lottery since 2004. Stuart Lustig, a child psychiatrist whose three-unit TIC is entering the condo lottery for the first time this year, likes the proposal in theory but wants to find out "how much it is going to cost to jump the line, as it were. "The city also will make more money when property taxes go up, when they reassess the units (as condos rather than TICs)." On the other hand, TIC owner Daniele Mills, an administrative assistant at Genentech, said she thinks the proposal doesn't seem democratic. "It has a lot of repercussions for people with less income than other people," she said.
Hearst Newspapers Be the first to share your thoughts on this story. Proposal: Pay fee, skip condo-conversion line BU Waiting to go condo is San Francisco's version of waiting for Godot. Building owners can spend years vying for one of 200 condo-conversion slots awarded annually via a lottery.
|