Berkeley CSUA MOTD:Entry 49997
Berkeley CSUA MOTD
 
WIKI | FAQ | Tech FAQ
http://csua.com/feed/
2025/05/28 [General] UID:1000 Activity:popular
5/28    

2008/5/18-23 [Science/Battery] UID:49997 Activity:low
5/18    I'm looking for a good rechargeable AA battery system. What do you guys
        use? I'm thinking of getting a bunch of AA NiMH and a really good
        charger that can do a full drain/recharge cycle to reduce memory
        effect as well as battery tender since NiMH seems to lose 10% charge
        per week, or AA Li-Ion with normal chargers. What do you guys think?
        \_ http://www.steves-digicams.com/nimh_batteries.html
        \_ http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?t=79302
           The candlepower guys are scary about batteries.  It's pretty
           strange how much variance there is between simalarly rated
           batteries, both in prefered load and total wattage.
        \_ I wouldn't bother with "regular" NiMH, unless your usage
           pattern is "charge, use aggressively within a week,
           repeat."  The obvious choice for the low-self-discharge
           type is the Sanyo Eneloop, but I've had success with
           cheaper Hybrio stuff (batteryjunction.com).  I hear the new
           MAHA Imedion are very good, too.  As for the charger, I own
           two MAHA C401FS as well as a MAHA C9000.  I think C9000 is
           a neat toy and useful at times, but most of the time, I
           stick to C401FS.  I hear LaCrosse charger is fine, too, as
           long as you avoid the earlier revision.
           \_ How's the usability for MAHA? I've heard a lot of bad
              things, like having to input 48 keystrokes to charge
              4 batteries properly. LAME.
              \_ Yeah, it takes fair amount of key presses to make it do
                 interesting stuff, but I don't find it annoying at all.
           \_ I recently got a LaCrosse charger, and love it.
           \_ Eneloops are awesome, now you can use rechargables electronics
              that don't need new batteries every month.
              \_ How are Eneloops different from other NiMH rechargable
                 batteris?  I bought the Eneloop package from Costco
                 (AA and AAA batteries and charger in blue plastic case), and
                 I'm using it just like the other rechargable batteries
                 (e.g. Panasonic NiMH) that I have.  I haven't been paying
                 attention at its performance.
                 \_ Regular rechargables lose charge very quickly even if
                    they aren't used.  (Like within a month.)  It makes
                    them pretty much useless for electronics that don't
                    get regular use (or have a low power draw).  Eneloops
                    on the other hand keep their charge for years.  Also
                    they seem to last longer under high draw usage than cheap
                    rechargables do, even ones rated the same mah or higher.
        \_ I don't use rechargeable. Alkalines are pretty cheap nowadays
           and they last 2-3X as long. Besides, 1.5V >> 1.2V. This whole
           1.2V thing really renders rechargeable useful for only a short
           amount of time before they drop to unusable voltage.
           \_ Alkalines drop to 1.2V very quickly.  Rechargables stay at or
              above 1.2V just as long as alkalines.
              \_ doubtful. I get about 30 flashes with a brand new NiMH
                 rated at 2200mA, whereas I get over 100 flashes with
                 alkaline. As a photographer, I can't afford to have to
                 switch batteries all the time, or an extra clunky 12V
                 NiMH pack at 5-8 pounds on my belt.
                 \_ http://batteryboulevard.com/alkaline-aa-15-volt-vs-nimh-aa-12-volt-smackdown
                    Also it really depends on the NiMH batteries you use.
                    \_ Again, whatever people say is still FULL OF SHIT
                       unless they provide an exact voltage/amp chart
                       of different appliances in respect to time. What is
                       the curve, drop off point, etc. You can't just say
                       X is better than Y or vice versa without knowing
                       exactly what the driving appliance is, and what the
                       useful voltage for that appliance is, and what the
                       chart looks like. Full of shit. Aspolito you're full
                       of shit as expected. Try again.
                       \_ Oh aren't you a cranky little pissant.  There are
                          plenty of battery geeks who have done voltage over
                          time charts that support me.  I frankly don't give
                          enough of a shit to hunt down the data for some
                          asshole.  Fuck it.  Keep using non rechargable
                          batteries.  It's not like they aren't a major
                          source of environmental damage and toxic landfill
                          waste.
                          \_ Ok I lied.  I do give enough of a shit.
                             http://www.powerstream.com/AA-tests.htm
                             \_ Cool link, and thanks for trolling, and
                                you're a fucking loser.
                                \_ People with any social skills apologize
                                   when they attack someone and are proven
                                   wrong.  You may want try it someday.
                                   \_ dude, you're STUPID
                                      \_ Are you saying he's stupid because
                                         he's still conversing with a dick?
                                         \_ you got trolled             !op
                                          \_ Trolls are still dicks.
                             \_ Thanks for the link.  It seems that NiMH
                                is superior to all but Lithium?  I guess
                                the Energizer Lithium is not rechargeable?
                                -jrleek
                                \_ Lithium batteries do bad things when
                                   recharged poorly.  Explosivly bad things.
        \_ On a somewhat related note, I have a MAHA C401FS and Maha Powerex
           and Duracell batteries I got a few years ago. I really haven't used
           them all that much (maybe 20 times). There was a period of
           maybe a year where I didn't use them at all. A few months ago,
           I had occasion to use them again, but the batteries and/or
           charger seem not to be working anymore (the batteries don't seem to
           hold a charge for long). I read recently that these NiMH batteries
           need to be charged on a regular basis, or else they lose their
           ability to hold a charge? This seems really lame. My batteries
           are only maybe 3 years old. Anyone else seen this happen?
           \_ I recently found some pretty ancient energizer NiMH batteries
              (6+ years old?) that I hadn't used for at least 3-4 years
              and they still seem to work well.
           \_ You need to 'refresh' them, ie, go through several
              charge/discharge cycle to bring back the full power.
              Some chargers like the LaCrosse do this automatically
              for you when you select that mode.
2025/05/28 [General] UID:1000 Activity:popular
5/28    

You may also be interested in these entries...
2009/1/7-12 [Science/Battery, Computer/SW/OS/OsX] UID:52329 Activity:low
1/7     new macbook 17" THE BIG ONE not the portable, has a non removable
        8 hour battery.  Dicuss.
        \_ it's like the airbook
           \_ no it's not, it's giant and i'm not going to carry that thing
        \_ stupid idea, will alienate customers.
         \_ Who will it alienate?  Assuming they can get longer battery
	...
2008/8/29-9/3 [Science/Battery] UID:50997 Activity:nil
8/29    I have 2 AA rechargeable batteries. One is at 300mAH and the other
        one is at 600mAH. They used to be 2400mAH. Is there anything useful
        I can use them for?
        \_ How do you know this?
           \_ http://www.amazon.com/Crosse-Technology-BC-900-AlphaPower-Battery/dp/B00077AA5Q/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1220035985&sr=8-1
           \_ http://www.amazon.com/Crosse-Technology-BC-900-AlphaPower-Battery/dp/B00077AA5Q
	...
Cache (8192 bytes)
www.steves-digicams.com/nimh_batteries.html
Steve's Digicams Rechargeable Batteries Last updated April 2, 2007 (prices may change without notice) The first thing a new digicam owner quickly realizes is that those AA alkaline batteries included with their camera are next to worthless. I've gotten many emails from folks who wondered if their cameras were defective because they only got 20 or so shots before the batteries crapped out. Today's digital cameras are extremely high-drain devices. The batteries must power a color LCD, a motorized zoom lens, an autofocus system, the multi-megapixel imager and the associated processing hardware. Over the last couple of years we've seen higher capacity NiMH batteries hit the market, especially in the popular AA size which is what most of the digicams use. The first cells were only 800-900mAh capacity but now we have a wide choice of cells ranging from 1500 to 2700mAh. As expected, the higher the capacity - the longer the run time. Jump to CR-V3 Li-ion Rechargeables NiMH Rechargeable Batteries (Actual prices may be lower than shown below) High Power NiMH Batteries 2700mAh now that's what I call power! If you're still using two year old (or older) NiMH batteries - replace them with a new set of 2500mAh or 2700mAh cells - you won't believe the difference in power and stamina with the newer technology cells! And check out the Sanyo Eneloop and Uniross Hybrio cells, these are new technology NiMH batteries that are ready to use out of the package, can be recharged in any good NiMH charger and they hold a charge for months when not used. The advanced technology used in Hybrio batteries allows them to retain a long-term charge (90% @ 6 months, 85% @ 1 year) - even if they are not used - and they can be recharged up to 500 times. gradient line Want to know technically how these batteries rate? After a fully automatic test cycle, percentage of remaining battery capacity is indicated on the LED bar display. Battery types are clearly labeled next to appropriate contacts. There are no settings, and test results are easy to understand. Its small size makes it ideal for the gadget bag or home utility drawer. MH-C9000 WizardOne Charger/Analyzer - Maha's most significant product in five years: the MH-C9000 WizardOne Battery Charger & Analyzer. Suitable for the casual consumer users, enthusiast and professionals, WizardOne is capable of charging, conditioning, analyzing, cycling, forming and discharging one to four AA or AAA batteries, all while digitally displaying the battery capacity and voltage. All four slots can be operated independently in different modes and settings. The large LCD screen, backlit by ultra-bright white LEDs and measuring over 35 by 15, is more than three times larger than its closest competition and shows a wealth of information that is easy to read. In addition to the standard charging, conditioning and discharging, the WizardOne charger- analyzer also offers two unusual operations modes. The Break-In mode allows the user to input the capacity of the battery and performs a forming charge designed to properly break- in new batteries. The Cycle mode allows user to charge and discharge batteries consecutively while storing the capacity for up to 15 cycles. There are ten selectable charging and discharging current from 02A to 20A and 01A to 10A respectively. The charger also features four independent temperature sensors using Mahas latest temperature rise detection algorithm in addition to the usual peak temperature detection. It also armed with additional patented termination algorithms found in other Maha chargers. In the basic mode, user merely needs to insert the batteries with no further key press. The charger will select the appropriate settings automatically, making it suitable for the casual users. The MH-C9000 ships with a worldwide travel power supply. LaCrosse BC-900 Advanced Charger (updated model) Charges one, two, three or four AA or AAA size NiMH or older NiCd type cells. Individual LCD data displays for each of the cells being charged. Comes bundled with four 2000mAh AA and four 700mAh NiMH cells, deluxe padded carrying case, 4 C- and D-size cell adapters. You can visually see each cell's charging current (settable from 200 to 1800mAh), voltage, charging time, accumulated capacity and discharge current. You can have four different rates of charging current going at the same time if desired. Refresh older batteries with an automatic charge/discharge up to 20 cycles or until battery is refreshed to full capacity. Uses both voltage and temperature to protect against over-charging and goes into safe trickle mode to maintain full power after charging cycle is completed. Features 8 Independent Charging Circuits - Charges any combination of 1 to 8 batteries. Mix and charge AA / AAA rechargeable batteries all at the same time. Normal Charge time of about 1 hr regardless of the number of AA or AAA batteries. Soft charge mode recharges in about 2hrs regardless of the number of AA or AAA batteries. LCD Display - shows charging and conditioning status of each battery independently. Built-In Deep Battery Conditioning System - Cycle charges, discharges, and then recharges batteries without requiring several repeat cycles. Selectable Soft and Rapid Charge Modes - Soft charge option for highest battery life, or choose the Rapid charge option for the shortest charge time. Heavy Duty International AC Adapter - Universal auto-ranging switching adapter assures Worldwide voltage compatibility. Mix and charge AA / AAA / C / or D rechargeable batteries all at the same time. Normal Charge time of about 1 hr regardless of the number of AA / AAA or 2 to 5 hrs for C and D rechargeable batteries with the Maha MH-C808M charger. Soft charge mode recharges in about 2hrs regardless of the number of AA or AAA batteries. LCD Display shows charging and conditioning status of each rechargeable battery independently. Cycle charges, discharges, and then recharges rechargeable batteries without requiring several repeat cycles. Restores rechargeable batteries to their optimal performance level. Soft charge option for highest battery life, or choose the Rapid charge option for the shortest charge time. Heavy Duty International AC Adapter, universal auto-ranging switching adapter assures Worldwide voltage compatibility. The Sony BCG-34HRMD Super Quick Charger for 2 or 4 AA or AAA NiMH cells. As you can see, it has an LCD display on the front to show the state of the charge of each of the cells being charged. It's bundled with four Sony 2300mAh NiMH AA cells and will recharge two/four cells in 135/270 minutes. It can charge two/four 800mAh AAA size cells in 70/140 minutes. The refresh cycle takes 45 hours for 1-4 2300mAh AA cells. This charger uses voltage monitoring with a safety timer and temperature monitoring function. It runs worldwide on 100 - 240V AC with a builtin power supply and an interchangeable AC cord. The Maha PowerEx MH-C204W One Hour Worldwide charger can be used internationally without the need of a power brick. An integrated 100-240V 50/60Hz worldwide switching adapter is built into the charger and comes with an interchangeable AC cord. The MH-C204W has an integrated battery conditioner to rescue old and degraded NiMH batteries by applying high current pulses. The MH-C204W can reach a 98% charge level in the batteries when the lights turn green, without the risk of undercharging or overcharging! It has four unique charging phases: startup charge, rapid charge, top-off charge and maintenance charge. The startup charge delivers a smooth ramp-up of current when the batteries are inserted. The top-off charge is applied for two hours after the completion of the charge to ensure that batteries are topped off to their maximum capacity. The low rate pulse maintenance charge ensures that batteries are not overcharged when left in the charger for extended periods of time and are always ready to use. Finally, the microprocessor driven negative Delta V, Zero Delta V and the temperature termination system ensure complete charging. Lenmar Mach1 Gamma Speed Charger is the next fastest charger that we have used to date. It charges one to four AA or AAA cells...
Cache (8192 bytes)
www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?t=79302
Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Bellingham WA Posts: 9,223 Default NiMh Battery Shoot Out Last Revision Date, 3/11/2008 I will add graphs as I finish the testing. If you have some NiMh cells that you would like to see the test results of, contact me for my shipping address so I can borrow a couple of cells for testing. The graphs will pretty much speak for themselves, so let's get started... Brock asked me to put up a comparison at a 10 amp discharge rate. I thought of doing this type of graph for all the discharge rates, but decided to do individual graphs to show the performance range of the different cells. This graph was getting extremely cluttered, so I have replaced it with a table. JT loaned me a couple of Quest Platinum AA cells that are rated at 2300 mAh. Sigbjoern loaned me some Kodak AA 1700 mAh cells and here is how they perform. A big thanks to Sigbjoern, he also loaned me some of the CBP AA 1650 mAh cells. To get the maximum performance from the CBA 1650 cells, you need to run them hot. CAUTION: Running lights on these hot cells may result in insta-flashing the lamp. Here are the results on the Energizer AA 2300 mAh cells. Here is the graph of the Energizer AA 2300 mAh cells that Brody sent me. I am not sure why there is such a difference between his cells and mine, but his are more in line with what I expected from these cells. I am not sure who makes these cells, but they have a green sleeve and are rated 1400 mAh. They were part of a promotion when I got my charger and I believe they are very inexpensive. I took the results of an average cell, but be advised that each cell (of the 4 I have) tested differently and the range from highest to lowest was about 30%. I have learned to lower my expectations of free cells... Here is the data from some Radio Shack 1500 mAh cells I have been using. They hold voltage very well and are capable of some misuse as well. I have been using these cells in my Battery Charger Shoot Out and have been very impressed with them. I have also been impressed that they are very consistent from cell to cell. They may not be the best in a 10 amp application, but they do very well for a consumer grade cell. Brody pointed out in a post below that other people testing batteries have found the Titanium 2400 cells to be very good as well. Wayne, if you happen to read this, thanks for an excellent AA cell and I hope you don't feel the need to change it. Here are the graphs of the Titanium 2400 I am also very impressed with the Titanium 2000 cells. They have the same ability to keep a higher voltage during discharge, but just have a bit less capacity. It almost seems to me that the cells are put through a sorting process and the high capacity cells are the 2400's and if they don't meet the higher capacity, they go into the 2000 bin. These cells are also very consistent from cell to cell and perform very well. These are interesting in that the harder you hit them, the better they perform. I also have these cells as do most people that purchased the La Crosse charger. There is some inconsistency between cells, but it is not too bad. Brody also sent me some Sanyo HR Industrial AA 2500 cells. Brody also sent me some Sunpack AA 2300 mAh cells to check out. I am not sure what Sunpack is trying to do here, but their cells don't even come close to 2300 mAh. com the same people that have the excellent charger the Lightning Pack 4000N. The only issue I have with this charger is that it charges pairs of cells rather than individual cells. These cells are designed to work with the Ray O Vac IC3 15 minute charger, but can be charged by other chargers as well. At the end of charge, the IC3 cells interrupt the circuit and the Energizer 15 minute charger would start the charge cycle again. Several rounds of this and you end up with a IC3 cell getting hot and an Energizer 15 minute charger with a blinking red light indicating something is wrong. These are the cells that come with the Energizer 15 minute charger. I am not sure how these cells fit into use categories, but I have noticed that GP has some high performance (high current) cells that work best "hot off the charger." I tested these cells using my normal cool down because I believe this is representative of how we would use these cells in our lights. These are geared to high current draw applications and do quite well. These are GP 1100 mAh cells and I am very impressed with their performance. You will notice the similarities in the 15 and 20 amp curves. The 20 amp test was done with cells hot off the charger. When the cells cool down, they fall on their face at 20 amps. The test at 50 amps was done with "warm" cells (about 90 F) to see what effect a little temperature has. You have to love a cell that gives it rated capacity at 3C. Lasercrazy loaned me some Powerex AA 2300 mAh cells to check out. These cells check out for perhaps 1800 mAh cells, but are nowhere close to 2300 mAh cells. Lasercrazy also loaned me some Ansmann AA 2300 mAh cells. I am not sure who makes these cell, but they did pretty well. Thanks, and sorry it took so long to get them back to you. They are looking pretty good If I asked you to run down to the local store and pick up some Vapextech NiMh batteries, would you look at me and wonder what I was talking about? If you live across the pond you may be familiar with this brand, but I am not sure it is available in the US. They are performing well at 5 amps, but fall on their face at 10 amps, so I can believe they could hold up at 75 amps. If you happen to see these cells, dont be afraid to purchase them. AmondoTech is offering some Titanium AAA 1000 mAh cells. There are not many AAA cells that can hold up to a 30 amp discharge rate and maintain descent voltage. com sent me some Powerex AA 2500 mAh cells to check out. I had tested some Powerex cells earlier, and they did not perform very well. I decided to really put these cells through their paces to see how well they perform. In addition to the test runs, I used these cells in my PT Yukon Extreme and my Mag85 for several cycles. I have come to the conclusion that these are very good cells. They perform very well at high loads as well as at lower loads, and they seem to be holding up over the 40+ cycles I have put them through. I dont know what happened to the earlier cells that I tested, but these 2500s are very good performers. I ran a test at a 75 amp draw because I was told that these cells were designed to hold over 10 volts at 3C. At 10 amps they kind of fall on their face, but they did not heat up and thats a lot better than most consumer cells do. UnderDog sent me some Sanyo Eneloop cells to check, along with the Sanyo NC-MDR02 charger. This is a 2 cell charger and I have not had a chance to fully check it out, but it is on the list. The advantage of the Eneloop cells is that they have a reduced self discharge rate. Sanyo advertises that they have 85% of their original capacity after 1 year of room temperature storage. Keep in mind that the self discharge rate goes up at elevated temperatures. Did you notice that at 10 amps the voltage is still holding above 10 volts? The self discharge test revealed that in 31 days there is 93% of the original capacity remaining. I do not know if this self discharge rate remains linear, but in discussing the new battery chemistry with Wayne at AmondoTech, he mentioned that he is under the impression that the self discharge rate slows down the longer the cell is stored. It does not completely stop, but it is slowed down to almost nothing. If we assume that what I measured in 31 days is linear (worst case), that means that at the end of a year you would end up with about 44% of the original capacity remaining. Considering that with a normal NiMh cell you would end up with 0% capacity left, this is still quite an accomplishment. I tested a Sanyo 2500 mAh cell that has been stored at room temperature for 30 days. Andy (MorePower) sent me some RayOVac Hybrid cells to check out. These are also low self discharge rate cells, and they did a very good job. I have them at retaining around 86% of their initial capacity after 30 days. Not quite as good as the Enel...
Cache (2870 bytes)
batteryboulevard.com/alkaline-aa-15-volt-vs-nimh-aa-12-volt-smackdown
Click stars to vote (left is low, right is high) 1 Star 2 Stars 3 Stars 4 Stars 5 Stars (No Ratings Yet) Loading ... There are concerns regarding the voltage difference between using a 15 volt alkaline battery and a 12 volt NiMH (Nickel Metal-Hydride) rechargeable battery. There is a question wondering if the 15 volt is actually giving better power because it starts at a higher voltage. Some wonder why it is better to use a 12 volt rechargeable NiMH battery instead of the 15 volt primary alkaline which is rated with higher voltage. There is even some mild suspicion of being "ripped off" with the lower voltage. First of all, unless the device's instructions specifically says you must use alkaline 15 volt batteries, the 12 volt NiMH batteries will perform just a well if not better. Although rated at 15 volts, alkaline AA batteries only deliver this rating when fully charged. The alkaline begins at 15 volts, but the minute it begins discharging, the voltage will continuously drop and will decrease for the life of the battery. The average voltage of alkaline batteries is actually about 12 volts which is very close to the NiMH rechargeable AA battery. Once the alkaline battery discharges down to 50% of its capacity, it delivers less than 10 volts which is a lower voltage than the NiMH AA battery. On the other hand, NiMH AA battery begins at 12 volts and stays at this voltage for 80% of its discharge cycle. There is less signal loss or weakening of power with the NiMH rechargeables because the voltage stays strong most of the life of the discharge. The characteristic to be aware of is how the voltage can drop off rather quickly at the end of the discharge cycle, and the batteries will need replacing. So if you are near the end of a discharge cycle on a set of batteries, it often is better to change them out before you miss a camera shot or have your recording device stop at a crucial moment. Just put them on the charger and they'll be ready when it's time to change them out again. Share This Post - instructions included The Editor: April Lankford, Technical Director & Editor About: April Lankford has been a television and media technical operating engineer for over 30 years and has watched the development of batteries along with other multi-media technology. By using recently available rechargeable power, we do definitely help the environment, but we also directly and immediately benefit by saving money as well. D Our goal is to provide a place where inquiry and research find answers. We want to satisfy a wide spectrum of battery users, from the experienced technician who has been somewhat skeptical about newer rechargeable battery technology, and the average household consumer intimidated with anything too complicated. This site is our way of sharing information with you and ensuring you emerge an educated battery consumer.
Cache (2069 bytes)
www.powerstream.com/AA-tests.htm
How to design battery packs Special Design Rules for Large Battery Packs Testing AA cells Method 1 New Batteries are purchased from a retailer to make sure they are fresh. This is reliable only above 100 mA, so the discharge tests below are for relatively high currents, in other words digital cameras. The performance rankings may be different for low current applications. This test compares the different manufacturer's cells at 2 amps discharge rate. Note that at 2 Amps discharge rate the Radio Shack (RS) has higher voltage and more amp hours than the Duracell Coppertop (DC). At a slow discharge rate the Duracell pulls out ahead slightly, both for the voltage and the amp hours. I don't have the patience to run it at lower amp rates, but for very low discharge applications you might find that the Coppertop excells the Radio Shack even more. Evidently the Radio Shack cell was designed for high current and the Coppertop is designed for low curent. This is the PowerStream 2000 mAH Nickel Metal Hyrdide cell. I was surprised at how this cell shines for high current applications. The green and red curves were the same cell run twice at 2 amps. Evidently for high current applications the rechargeable battery is a much better choice, both for amp hours and for keeping the voltage high during discharge. I still use the disposable because of the convenience, but both for total cost and number of pictures between battery changeout there is a good reason to use these rechargeable cells. PowerStream Technology: 140 South Mountainway Drive, Orem Utah 84058 Phone: 801-764-9060, 9062, 9063, or 9064 Custom DC/DC Converters Fax: 801-764-9061 PowerStream Technology 140 South Mountainway Dr. Map & Directions Copyright 2000-2004, 2006, 2007 Lund Instrument Engineering, Inc. All rights reserved This material is copyrighted original work. It is forbidden to use this information, text, or graphics in full or in part on another web site without written permission. This prohibition forbids making derivative text using automatic thesaurus substitution software.