www.csua.org/u/hen -> nrd.nationalreview.com/article/?q=Njk5NTU2YmEwMTRiODZhZTZmNjliNGJlMjcwYjNmMTk=
POLITICS The Death of the Moderate Democrat And the birth of the netroots party BYRON YORK The scene is one of those Washington cocktail parties so hated by left-wing netroots activists a gathering where politicians and pundits and inside-the-Beltway types meet to gossip, conspire, make deals, and generally sink farther into their morass of inside-the-Beltway corruption. One prominent member of Congress says to a prominent political analyst: You know, if you think about it, Nancy Pelosi is pretty close to the center of the House Democratic caucus. It seems hard to believe, given that Pelosi, the Minority Leader, is a true-blue San Francisco liberal with a near-perfect 95 rating from the left-wing Americans for Democratic Action. But the analyst starts thinking, starts envisioning the House Democratic lineup, beginning on the left with the Black Caucus, and then the Hispanic Caucus, and then the white lefties, and then Pelosi. In that cast of characters, the congresswoman from San Francisco seems almost, well, centrist. That doesnt mean shes a moderate, the analyst says, recalling the conversation at the party. But the Democratic caucus has gone so far to the left that, hell, shes in the middle. Theres been much talk in Washington recently about the fate of moderate Democrats. These days, Nancy Pelosi is a moderate Democrat if that is defined as standing near the center of the partys ideological spectrum. But the truly moderate Democrat the type of centrist that has been so maligned by the left-wing blogosphere is pretty much a thing of the past. Americans for Democratic Action rates House members on a scale from 0 to 100 based on how they have voted on issues important to various liberal constituencies. In 1985, when there were 253 Democrats in the House, 20 were ADA All-Stars that is, they had perfect scores of 100. In 2005, when there were 202 Democrats in the House, there were 65 All-Stars. An astonishing 143 about 71 percent of the Democratic caucus had scores of 90 or above. By way of comparison, in 1985, when there were 182 Republicans in the House, nine had perfect 100 conservative scores as measured by the American Conservative Union. In 2005, when there were 232 Republicans in the House, 38 of them had perfect ACU scores. A total of 126 about 55 percent of the Republican caucus had conservative scores of 90 or above. The numbers are similar in todays Senate, where 22 of 45 Democrats have received the ADAs most liberal rating. Forty Democratic senators about 90 percent of the Democratic caucus have ADA ratings of 90 or above. By contrast, out of the Senates 55 Republicans, only twelve have received the ACUs highest mark. A total of 34 Republicans about 62 percent of the Republican caucus have ACU ratings of 90 or above. The numbers are by no means scientific, and there are some differences in the ADA and ACU ratings systems. But as rough guides to party positioning, the ratings especially each sides ratings of its own team measure how well lawmakers satisfy the expectations of interest groups on the left and right. These numbers suggest that, while neither the House nor the Senate is a hotbed of centrism, Democrats in recent years have moved farther to the left than Republicans have to the right. Today, after years of drifting leftward, Democrats face a dilemma. They are the target of an angry, energized netroots movement that considers the mainstream Democratic party too centrist, too accommodating to Republicans, and insufficiently progressive for todays politics. The farther Democrats move to the left, the farther their most passionate constituents prod them along. To read this article in full, you need to be logged in as an NR / Digital subscriber. You will be automatically redirected to this article after successfully logging in below.
Just enter your account number below and hit the submit button. Account number: Example mailing label (Your mailing label should look similar to the sample shown above. The sample account number is shown highlighted in yellow.
|