5/11 Hi guys. Is JIRA all that? We have Bugzilla too, but JIRA looks nice,
and we can afford it. Thanks.
\_ It was the leading candidate in our attempt to replace Bugzilla,
but there were enough problems with it that we decided not to use
it. (The status of the replacement project is undetermined.) My
biggest complaint was that the search interface sucks, both in
terms of UI and power. I also didn't much care for the fact that
email preferences are per-project and not per-user, so I can't
adjust when I get email. The lack of Bugzilla's "watch user"
feature is a problem too; although some aspects of notification
schemas are better than user watching, they don't cover the same
set of features. I also just didn't like the UI -- every action
requires opening a new page, it's clunky, important information
isn't presented very well, and it keeps rather more state than
I would like (so clicking on one link, clicking a second link,
and clicking the first link again doesn't bring me back to the
same page). It seems like it's not well built for the way we work.
There are features we like, just not enough to overcome the things
we didn't like. -gm
\_ We switched to JIRA. All the things that gm doesn't like, except
for the back page stuff, you can control by setting up custom
work flows. This takes time though. -ausman
\_ Thanks guys. |