12/17 I don't care about people saying "Happy Holidays" but calling a
Christmas tree a "Holiday Tree" throws me. What other holidays
use a lit up evergreen tree? Yule I guess. Who exactly is
supposed to be included by calling it a "holiday tree?" -jrleek
\_ The tree thing seems stupid, I agree. Happy Holidays , on the
other hand, has a useful, distinct, meaning and it has nothing
to do with being PC. It's thanksgiving + christmas + new year +
channukah, and you can keep saying it for about a month, without
bothering to look at the date. Does it really make sense to say
"merry christmas" on the 20th? And surely not the 26th.
\_ What is your problem? Don't you see the holidy on 25th of
December is all about family gathering and gift giving.
If you want to celebrate the birth of Christ on the wrong year,
wrong month, and wrong date of month, be my guest, but most
people simply don't care about the origin of the holiday.
And that is nothing wrong with that. And by the way, people do
call it Chrismas tree, eventhough they are not religious.
\_ You've been living in a cave, have you?
\_ Muslims, Buddhists, and Liberals. America is a Christian
nation, and if they don't like it, they should leave. !williamc
\_ Oddly enough, this may the reason many non Christians have
trees. They want to be or appear more Americanized. They don't
want their family to felt left out of mainstream culture. When
in Rome...
\_ I'm non-Christian, and I have a tree. I grew up with it, it's
a tradition.. it's not overtly religious and doesn't have
particularly religious origins. I'm not doing it because I
"don't want to be left out of mainstream culture", I do it
because it's pretty and pleasant and something to put gifts
under.
\_ It's silly, though I do know people who don't celebrate Christmas,
in terms of "the Christian observance/mass celebrating Jesus' birth"
but do trim a tree. If you asked them, they'd call it a christmas
tree. "Holidy Tree" is an example of stupidity. Not disrespect.
And on the "Happy Holidays" thing.. I'm on my 8th season as a
professional caroler, and I'll generally say Happy Holidays. Though
if I'm at a house party with a tree and nativity set, I'll say
Merry Christmas. And when I sing something for the lesbian Jewish
couple's baby, I'll say Happy Channukah..The phrase you choose
is about your own level of politeness/respect for your audience.
It doesn't/shouldn't insult/ injure the audience. --scotsman
\_ It's a festivus tree.
\_ Yeah, it does sound weird. My family is not Christian, but we
did have a decorated "Christmas Tree" in our house during
the holidays. Though it is sort of funny that there is such
a big fuss over this symbolic use of an evergreen, since it
does not originally have anything to do with Xtianity.
did not originally have anything to do with Xtianity.
\_ I think it reminds suburbanites of nature that they've paved
over.
\_ So you live in a rural area? What time do you milk the cows?
\_ We should start formally calling it "Xmas" like in Futurama.
\_ Xmas happens in January when Steve gives us new koolaid.
\_ I dunno. My jewish friends that get a tree every year call it a
Christmas tree. -dans |