4/19 Related to the poll below re which era you would like to visit.
If you could go back in time and witness one battle which one
would you pick? Personally I'd choose the Battle of Marathon.
\- i assume you have read your herodotus. you might
read s. pressfield: gates of fire if you have not
already. in a different time, if interested in battle
details and a story better than da vinci code, see
e.g. "the archers tale" by bernard cornwell. decent quick
pulp read ... long description of crecy. and of course
A Distant Mirror is a classic. have not read Solider
in the Fog. btw, thucydides >>>> herodotus. ok tnx.
\- Why marathon and not thermopylae?
O xein angellein Lakedaimoniois hoti tede
keimetha tois keinon rhemasi peithomenoi
Might pick Agincourt or Crecy, maybe Zama or Gaugmela,
Cannae or Teutoberger Wald/Clades Variana, Pharsala or
Actium or Salamis. --psb
\_ iirc, Marathon came first and basically ensured
that Greek civilization (specifically Athens)
would survive. Also Marathon was a real victory
in which the good guys mostly walked away unscathed
vs. Thermopylae in which the good guys (Leonidas
and the 300 Spartan Hoplites) got killed.
\- i thought you were going for the drama factor. um,
"good guys" here is clearly a "relative term". if you
are filled with hate for persians, set your time
machine to gaugmela. i think it would be pretty cool
to hang out with agricola or marcus aurelius or any of
the "good emperors" for a season. i suppose it might
be horribly fascinating for some to see what exactly
tiberius did after retiring to capri. tagging along
for the melian dialog would be pretty amazing.
cannae would be more interesting than marathon. --psb
\_ The one where the Romans attacked Syracuse and got their asses
kicked by devices designed by Archimedes. That would have to have
been a good day to be a nerd.
\- i assume you have read your herodotus. you might
read s. pressfield: gates of fire if you have not
already. in a different time, if interested in battle
details and a story better than da vinci code, see
e.g. "the archers tale" by bernard cornwell. decent quick
pulp read ... long description of crecy. and of course
A Distant Mirror is a classic. have not read Solider
in the Fog. btw, thucydides >>>> herodotus. ok tnx.
\- Why marathon and not thermopylae?
O xein angellein Lakedaimoniois hoti tede
keimetha tois keinon rhemasi peithomenoi
Might pick Agincourt or Crecy, maybe Zama or Gaugmela,
Cannae or Teutoberger Wald/Clades Variana, Pharsala or
Actium or Salamis. --psb
\_ Why the FUCK is it so hard for you to indent like a normal
person?
\_ emacs is lame.
\- E_FOOLISHCONSISTENCY
\_ iirc, Marathon came first and basically ensured
that Greek civilization (specifically Athens)
would survive. Also Marathon was a real victory
in which the good guys mostly walked away unscathed
vs. Thermopylae in which the good guys (Leonidas
and the 300 Spartan Hoplites) got killed.
\- i thought you were going for the drama factor. um,
"good guys" here is clearly a "relative term". if you
are filled with hate for persians, set your time
machine to gaugmela. i think it would be pretty cool
to hang out with agricola or marcus aurelius or any of
the "good emperors" for a season. i suppose it might
be horribly fascinating for some to see what exactly
tiberius did after retiring to capri. tagging along
for the melian dialog would be pretty amazing.
cannae would be more interesting than marathon. --psb
\_ Anything big in WWII (assuming I get my invisible bullet-proof
flying bubble to watch it from.) -John |