Berkeley CSUA MOTD:Entry 36792
Berkeley CSUA MOTD
2019/12/10 [General] UID:1000 Activity:popular

2005/3/21 [Politics/Domestic, Politics/Domestic/Crime] UID:36792 Activity:high
3/21    The way I see the Schiavo case is as follows, it is just my opinion
        and you're free to criticize me if you want:
        -Scientists claim she has no consciousness, and that the probability
         of her regaining consciousness is less than 0.01%, which is
         unlikely. Let's just move on.
        -Family members and religious right activists say that all lives
         are sacred and that despite statistics and science, miracles   DO
         happen. Let's keep her alive.
        \_ Husband claims that Schiavo explicitly requested death over
           being kept alive artificially like she is.
           \_ yeah, after he smacked her so many times she ask
             him to just kill her off
           Also, ^Family members^parents (above)
        \_ I think you have a large number of mitigating factors.
           This is not a right to die case, there is no living will
           and testimony to her wish to die is suspect at best.
           Michael Schiavio's behavior is very suspicious and there
           alot of facts that are not publicized.
           \_ what the hell are you talking about?  there are lots of
              facts.  here is a list:
     - danh
              \_ i suspect less than 10% of US population is aware
                 of the full story involving her case and are basing
                 their judgement on what they see on the alphabet
                 networks.  No need to work yourself into a frenzy.
                 Are you aware of the conflicts of interest between
                 Schiavos lawyer?
                 Are you aware of affadavits from girlfriend stating
                 Michael denied ever discussing Terri's wish to die?
                 Are you aware he euthanized her cats so he could move
                 in with a girlfriend 2 years after her collapse?
                 Are you aware Michael was undergoing pyschological
                 counseling and on prescription drugs at the time
                 of her accident?
                 Are you aware judge Greer is legally blind?
                 \_ It's just a typical case of American blind justice, and
                    there ain't a-nothin' you can do about it.
                 Are you aware several women have restraining orders
                 on Michael?
                 \_ I have read stuff like "michael greer works
                    near the hospital in question and really annoyed
                    the staff about his vegetable wife's care, kind
                    of like an annoying cast member of ER, so someone
                    got a restraining order against michael".  this is a lot
                    different than random women getting restraining orders
                    against him.
                 \_ you mean the hospital staff does.
                 Are you aware Michael's testimony in the malpractice
                 suit contradicts his later testimony about her
                 wish to die?
                 Want more?
                 Murderers on death row get better treatment
                 than this.
    Since 1990, Theresa has lived in nursing homes with constant care. She is fe\
d and hydrated by tubes. The staff changes her diapers regularly. She has had nu\
merous health problems, but none have been life threatening.
    Over the span of this last decade, Theresa's brain has deteriorated because\
of the lack of oxygen it suffered at the time of the heart attack. By mid 1996,\
the CAT scans of her brain showed a severely abnormal structure. At this point,\
much of her cerebral cortex is simply gone and has been replaced by cerebral spi\
nal fluid. Medicine cannot cure this condition. Unless an act of God, a true mir\
acle, were to recreate her brain, Theresa will always remain in an unconscious,\
reflexive state, totally dependent upon others to feed her and care for her most private needs.
                 \_ tjb?  is that you?
                 \_ These are good to know, but the most important fact
                    is that there is no documentation of Terri's supposed
                    request to die. Michael could be wanting to sell her
                    organs to the highest bidder for all I care. We don't
                    know what Terri wanted and there is still a chance for
                    her to recover. Given that, she should be kept alive.
                    Anything else is murder, IMO.
                 \_ Why should the US population be aware of this case?
                    Even if all of the above were true, should Congress
                    intervene in this case?  What about in all similar
                    cases when a person in a vegetative state has relatives
                    who fight over the person's right to die?  Should
                    all those people ask Congress to intervene?
           \_ This whole affair is just political grandstanding by the
              Republicans, especially certain congressional leaders
              that have their eyes on 2008.  This is red meat for their
              base and everybody (including the public) knows it.
               \_ Exactly. Come 2008, and they'll say that Democrats are
                  evil heartless liberals, and that Republicans are
                  compassionate. Personally, I think the Democrats should
                  just give in on the basis of "compassion for election" -lib
                 \-If this schavio vegetable woman was say a portugese
                   woman and this drama was playing out in lisbon instead
                   of florida, would you "pro culture of life" people advocate
                   congress offering to bring her into the us and continue
                   feeding/hydratiing her? [assuming portugal and her parents
                   would be happy to let her move to the us, it could be done
                   safely, from a medical perspective etc]. --psb
                   \_ No.
                      \- why doesnt the culture of life apply here?
        \_ I think you are a superstitious loon.
2019/12/10 [General] UID:1000 Activity:popular

You may also be interested in these entries...
2014/1/7-2/5 [Reference/Religion, Politics/Foreign/Asia/China] UID:54762 Activity:nil
1/7     Are you from a family of Mormons, Cuban exiles, Nigerian Americans,
        Indian Americans, Chinese Americans, American Jews, Iranian Americans
        or Lebanese Americans? (
        \_ Somehow she misssed WASP Episcopalians.
2013/6/6-7/31 [Politics/Foreign/Asia/China, Computer/SW/Security] UID:54690 Activity:nil
6/6     Wow, NSA rocks. Who would have thought they had access to major
        data exchangers? I have much more respect for government workers,
        crypto experts, mathematicans now than ever.
        \_ flea to Hong Kong --> best dim-sum in the world
           \_ "flee"
        \_ The dumb ones work for DMV, the smart ones for the NSA. If you
2013/2/18-3/26 [Politics/Domestic/Election, Politics/Domestic/SIG] UID:54608 Activity:nil
2/18    F U NRA: (Sandy Hook Truthers)
           This shit makes me weep for America.
        \_ I didn't see any mention of the NRA on that page.  Did you mean "FU
           Crazy Conspiracy Theorists?"  Or do you have this really great
2012/11/6-12/18 [Politics/Domestic/California, Politics/Domestic/Election] UID:54524 Activity:nil
11/6    Four more years!
        \_ Yay! I look forward to 4 more years of doing absolutely nothing.
           It's a much better outcome than the alternative, which is 4 years
           of regress.
           \_ Can't argue with that.
        \_ Massachusetts went for Obama even though Mitt Romney was its
2012/7/21-9/24 [Politics/Foreign/Asia/China] UID:54440 Activity:nil
        This week's food for thought, brought to you by People's
        Republic of Berkeley: Did you know that many US pilots defected to
        communist Cuba?  South Korea pilots defected to communist
        North Korea? Iran<->Iraq pilots defected to each other?
        W Germany pilots defected to E Germany? Taiwan/ROC pilots
2013/6/18-8/13 [Reference/Law/Court, Politics/Domestic/Crime] UID:54695 Activity:nil
6/17    Don't mess with Texas:
        \_ Kudos.  I just worry that some shameless ambulance-chasing lawyer
           might sue her on behalf of the criminal.
           \_ America has more lawsuits per capita than any other nation.
              Lawyers, rejoice!!!
2012/9/19-11/7 [Politics/Foreign/MiddleEast/Israel] UID:54480 Activity:nil
9/18    Why are so many ACCOUNTANTS Jewish? Not a troll, just curious.
        Gil. Goldberg. Levy. etc...
        \_ Perhaps b/c historically Jews (unlike Christians) were allowed
           to charge interest on loans (usury).
           \_ ok, fine. What about lawyers? I don't get that one.
              Goldberg. Ginsberg. Buergenthal. Rosenthal. Hoffman. Shapiro.
2012/5/9-6/4 [Politics/Domestic/911] UID:54384 Activity:nil
5/9     If U.S. doesn't do assissination, then what do you call
        Operation Neptune Spear aka "Mission Kill Bin Laden"?
        \_ I think theoretically the difference is that the goal of one is
           "kill him/her", while the goal of the other is "capture him/her,
           and don't hestitate to shoot with the possibly of killing if he/she
           and don't hesitate to shoot with the possibly of killing if he/she
2010/7/5-20 [Politics/Domestic/Crime] UID:53875 Activity:nil
7/5     I think this is the first time a CA cop has EVER been put on trial
        for murdering a black man.
        \_ Really?  CA cop, or CA white cop?
        \_ The case marked the first murder prosecution of an on-duty Bay Area
           police officer. Prosecutors rarely file charges against police for
           shootings. A Chronicle review of police use-of-force cases around
2009/12/6-26 [Science, Politics/Domestic/President/Bush] UID:53570 Activity:nil
12/5    If Harry Potter is rewritten in a modern style using science
        instead magic, and using real people and references instead of
        fiction, what could it include? I'll start:
        -Slytherin Pureblood = Nazi Ayran
        -Muggle = melting pot
        -Dobby = Black slavery, illiterate
Cache (8192 bytes)
Here THE TERRI SCHIAVO INFORMATION PAGE As a Florida law blogger, I have created this page to help people underst and the legal circumstances surrounding the Terri Schiavo saga. In my vi ew, there continues to be a need for an objective look at the matter. Th ere is an unbelievable amount of misinformation being circulated. To be clear at the outset, I have no interest in taking any "side" in thi s dispute. Remarkably, I've been accused of being biased in favor of eac h side at one point or another. I have never met, spoken with, or even seen anyone in the Schiavo or Schindler families. I use first na mes on this web log simply for convenience, and my interest is simply as someone who enjoys Florida law and wishes to add some clarity to the ev ents here. Pick a given month's archives (linked on the right) since I s tarted this web log and you'll see what I mean. Finally, and without unnecessary elaboration, Ill point out that I sympa thize with everyone involved. More Information INITIAL THOUGHTS Before delving into the details of this case, I have two overarching sets of thoughts to share. Over the past 18 months, I suppose I've received thousands of emails concerning the Schiavo case. I've also read various message boards, and I've caught various talk radio and televisi on news discussions, all discussing this case. One thing I've observed r epeatedly is a sense of complete bewilderment by the public. I have a simple suggestion to anyone whose information about this case ju st leaves them befuddled about how "this" could be happening or how ever yone involved could be ignoring or overlooking "so much": Keep looking for more information. The facts of this case are terribly sad, but they are not hard to underst and. There's really nothing to be confused about, and as best I can tell , nothing's been overlooked by anyone. Terri's situation has arguably re ceived more judicial attention, more medical attention, more executive a ttention, and more "due process," than any other guardianship case in hi story. Terri's family has had the benefit of excellent legal representat ion as well as the Governor's own top-notch attorneys, all of whom have scoured the case for ways to assist the effort to keep Terri's feeding t ube in place. As you probably know (or will learn if you read the material below), Judge Greer held a full tri al in this case to determine how Terri would choose to exercise her priv acy rights. In the end, the judge ruled th at Terri would not wish to continue receiving nurishment and hydration t hrough a surgically implanted tube. Trials like this, where someone's life may literally be on the line, are held every day in courtrooms across the state and around the country. In every case, lawyers marshal witnesses , present evidence, and make arguments to further their clients' interes ts. The decisions made by the judge or jury may affect whether someone l ives or dies, whether someone spends his or her life in prison, or wheth er someone will have to pay another debilitating sums of money. Whether as a party, a witness, or a juror, those who have the opportunity to participate in trials should take their roles seriously, offering th eir best efforts to further the search for truth. At the same time, the public should realize that once a trial is over, the decision is made, a nd it was made based on the evidence. Appeals are almost always availabl e, but if the judgment is affirmed, only very rarely will there be an op portunity to get a new decision based on evidence not previously present ed. OVERVIEW In updating this page recently, I decided to include a summary about the case's events. After some efforts, it occurred to me that I should simpl y reproduce an email and my response that I recently blogged. Here's the email: Hi Matt, I stumbled across your site and quickly became immersed. I have been an avid follower of Terri Schiavo as I feel quite passionately about the c ase as explained in the letter I wrote to the Rocky Mountain News which was recently published (see below). So far, no amount of legal jargon has been able to quench my desperate desire to understand this case. I have been searching for answers for so very long, that I felt some sens e of relief when finding your site. I would really love to hear your op inion as to whether or not there is any hope whatsoever to save Terri a t this point, or is this it? Thank you so much in advance for your time and for listening. Here was my response: Thanks for the kind words and the sincere thoughts. This is a very tough situation for all involved -- and mind you I'm not at all involved. I just discuss the case as part of what seems to be my running commentary on Florida law. Ultimately, Terri's case is understandable, though painfully so. If you take away the "evil" all egations that have been leveled against everyone, it's easy to see what you're left with. You're left with a woman who suffered a heart attack 15 years ago, who e ssentially died but was resuscitated, though not entirely. Her brain ha d suffered enormous damage from the heart attack. As time passed, her b rain further deteriorated -- to the point where much if not most of her cerebral cortex (the portion of the brain that controls conscious thou ght, among other things) was literally gone, replaced by spinal fluid. Doctors hired by Terri's husband say the deterioration of Terri's brain left her without thoughts or feelings, that the damage is irreversible , and that Terri's life-like appearance is merely the result of brain s tem activity -- basically involuntary reflexes we all have. An independ ent doctor hired by the court reached the same conclusions. Doctors hir ed by Terri's parents did not dispute the physical damage done to Terri , but they claim there are new therapies that could improve her conditi on. In two separate trials, the trial court found such claims of potent ial improvement to be without merit. Terri's body continues to function without her cerebral cortex. She is sustained by a feeding tube surgic ally inserted into her stomach. She cannot eat through her mouth withou t a strong likelihood of choking to death. You're left with a husband who lived with his in-laws following Terri's heart attack, who apparently provided care and therapy for years but wh o later came to believe Terri would never recover. He believes she woul d not have wanted to be kept alive in this brain-degenerated condition by a surgically implanted tube. He is apparently willing to continue hi s fight to achieve what he believes Terri would want despite ridicule, hatred, expense, and threats. You're left with parents who were once allied with Terri's husband in an effort to care for Terri and restore her but, unlike Terri's husband, they never lost hope. They believe Terri reacts to them and has conscio us thoughts. They believe Terri would not want, and does not want, her feeding tube removed, and that some cognitive function could be restore d through new therapies. Terri's parents are willing to continue their fight to achieve what they believe Terri would want despite ridicule, h atred, expense, and threats. You're left with judges who have been placed in the utterly thankless po sition of applying Florida law to this impassioned situation. Florida l aw calls for the trial court to determine what Terri would chose to do in this situation, and after a trial hard fought by Terri's husband and her family, where each side was given the opportunity to present its b est case about what Terri would do, the court determined the evidence w as clear and convincing that Terri would chose not to continue living b y the affirmative intervention of modern medicine -- that she would cho se to have her feeding tube disconnected. In a second trial, brought ab out by Terri's family's claims new therapies could restore her and that the existence of such a therapy would make her "change her mind," the trial court again heard evidence from all sides and determined that no new therapy presented any reasonable chance of restoring Terri's brain function. The propriety of these decisions -- from the sufficiency of t he evidence to t...