2/24 How do people who use a pen to write in Arabic and Hebrew avoid
smudging the letters as they write? This seems like a design flaw.
\_ I'm left handed and manage English just fine. Although when learning
Persian (also right to left), I did like the fact that there was
less smear potential.
\_ I'm amazed that my totally random post was replied to by a
lefty who's studied Persian. Go motd!
\_ Yeah. Sometimes I think we need to step back and truly
appreciate the utility of the motd.
\_ When I was little I would end up with the side of my hand totally
filthy with graphite. Now I don't have problems except with
particularly slow drying ink. Now that I think about it, my hand
position when writing looks a little contorted compared to most
peoples'. So I guess that's how I avoid smudging. -lefty
\_ I don't have preferences in terms of right or left hands. So,
when I start to learn how to write Chinese, I choose to write with
left hand for this particular reason.
\_ Does your handwriting look different from right-handed people's?
My brother's starting to write Chinese, and he keeps complaining
that the characters don't look right when he writes them with his
left (preferred) hand.
\_ huh? I thought Chinese is written left to right in PRC,
and it's top to bottom, then right to left, (so you get
more drying time) in Taiwan. Even people in Taiwan
go left to right when writing in horizontal rows as
opposed to traditional vertical rows. In fact, I have
a friend who is a lefty but writes Chinese with right
hand, because Chinese is more easily written with right
hand, as each character is written diagonally from top
left corner to bottom right corner.
\_ Pick up any Chinese book, and it's top to bottom, right to
left. That's why the cover page is on the bottom of the
book or the binding to the right, depending on your
perspective. And, yes, smudging was an issue when I learned
to write with the brush (or whatever it's called in English).
Though caligraphy was done on a very porous and therefore
quick-absorbing paper, and that ameliorates the problem
somwhat.
\_ In calligraphy, isn't your hand and arm not supposed
to be resting on the paper irregardless?
\_ Yep. The correct way to hold the pen has your hand
and wrist elevated above the paper. However, one still
has to account for jacket sleeves or just incorrect
posture.
\_ Chinese has been traditionally written top to bottom then
right to left for thousands of years. It was the PRC who
imported English-style writing to Chinese, together with
English characters for phonetics. Taiwan sticks with the
the traditional way of writing and phonetics.
the traditional way of writing and phonetics. -- Hong Kong
Chinese
\_ I am aware of that. I don't mind top to bottom but
why right to left (column wise)? It's inconsistent
with the top-left to bottom-right manner where
each character is written. - tainan taiwanese
\_ Good point. I have no idea. -- Hong Kong Chinese
\_ THERE ARE NO LEFT HANDED CHINESE.
\_ Haven't you seen when the 1.2 billion people in PRC clap their
hands, they clap their left hands over their right hands?
They are all left handed. -- troll
\_ Well, traditionally, left-handed kids are "trained" out of
their tendency to use their left hand. After all, the left
hand is the hand sinister. |