| ||||||
| 5/24 |
| 2005/1/28 [Politics/Domestic/SocialSecurity] UID:35943 Activity:high |
1/28 Krugman explains why Dubya's "blacks are shafted by social security"
claim is false, and the origins of the claim:
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/01/28/opinion/28krugman.html?oref=login&hp
username/pw: gnugnugnu
This is not to say that the Democrats who sent out the initial
e-mail petition weren't dumbasses, because they were - and I'm
not sure if even the truth can repair the damage.
\_ wow, I must be a prophet. after my rambling about blacks
and social security on the motd the other day, it's now
all over the news. even bush is following up on my motd
remarks.
\_ Yeah, he uses the same faulty logic. If you work for 10 years
and die, all that money you put into SS is gone, so a lower life
expectancy means your family gets screwed from SS unless you own
the account and your children can inherit it.
\_ So what about all the white guys who worked for 11 years
and died? They got slightly more screwed. And social
security is so our old folks don't end up on the street
eating from garbage cans, it is NOT a pension program.
\_ Sorry, I screwed up in my analysis. Indeed, this might
suggest that whites are being screwed, since they might
live longer (hence being taxed more) and then die before
age 65.
\_ I hope someday you come to realize what a dumbass you
are.
\_ This is countered by the fact that more blacks than whites
(percentage wise) are on disability.
\_ The problem with the article is that is reasoned and well laid
out. The sloganeering and "faith-based" logic of the Bush admin
will always convince the 51% of the country that put the current
set of neocon nuts in power of the veracity of whatever BS the
admistration is peddling at the moment.
admistration is peddling at the moment. See: death tax, tax
administration is peddling at the moment. See: death tax, tax
cuts, WMDs, clear skies, healthy forests, etc. |
| 5/24 |
|
| www.nytimes.com/2005/01/28/opinion/28krugman.html?oref=login&hp By PAUL KRUGMAN (NYT) Op-Ed 779 words Late Edition - Final , Section A , Page 23 , Column 1 ABSTRACT - Paul Krugman Op-Ed column says Pres Bush's claim that Social Security must be privatized to avert imminent crisis has fallen flat, so now he is playing race card; says he told African-American group that system is inherently unfair to blacks because they do not live long enough to collect their fair share of benefits; says Bush's use of that false argument is doubly shameful, because he is exploiting tragedy of high black mortality for political gain instead of treating it as problem to be solved; notes Social Security Administration's chief actuary has said that nonwhite population actually enjoys same or better expected rates of return from Social Security as whites Please Note: Archive articles do not include photos, charts or graphics. To read the complete article, simply click on one of the BUY NOW buttons below. You can buy this single article or, for even greater value, you can purchase this article as part of a multi-pack. You'll then have the opportunity to buy additional articles now or in the future at significant savings! Article Archive: 1996-Present multi-packs are not valid for use with Article Archive: 1851-1995 multi-packs and vice versa. How multi-packs work: A multi-pack is an archive package that saves you money by allowing you to pre-purchase a set number of articles in bulk at a reduced price. You can then debit from your multi-pack and quickly access articles from the archive at your convenience over the lifetime of the multi-pack. Please Note: Article Archive 1996-Present multi-packs are not valid for use with Article Archive: 1851-1995 multi-packs and vice versa. Once you purchase an article, you may view it as often as you like over the next 90 days. |