| ||||||
| 5/19 |
| 2005/1/12 [Politics/Foreign/MiddleEast/Iraq] UID:35676 Activity:high |
1/12 CNN (today)
"The search ended almost two years after President Bush ordered the
invasion of Iraq, citing concerns that Saddam Hussein was building
weapons of mass destruction and may have hidden weapons stockpiles."
Dubya (two years ago):
"Intelligence gathered by this and other governments leaves no doubt
that the Iraq regime continues to possess and conceal some of the
most lethal weapons ever devised."
Why can't CNN just be accurate? They can write:
"The search ended almost two years after President Bush ordered the
invasion of Iraq, citing intelligence that Saddam Hussein was building
weapons of mass destruction and concealing weapons stockpiles."
... isn't that much better?
\_ why the liberals are always wrong-- if the WMDs are found,
then Bush is right. If they're not, they've gone to Syria
or have been destroyed, and that means Bush is still right.
See how pointless it is to argue on this topic?
\_ This is where you tell them about David Kay. He was hand-picked
and blessed by Dubya, went in almost certain to find something,
and came back saying, "We were almost all wrong."
Then you tell them about Duelfer--Kay's replacement and also
hand-picked and blessed by Dubya--and his same conclusion that
Saddam had destroyed all his stockpiles and did not have any
active WMD programs and strove to keep them dismantled so he
could get UN sanctions lifted.
So, if there weren't any stockpiles, how could Saddam give them
to Syria?
It was only after the UN stopped monitoring at which he would
rebuild his WMD programs.
\_ um, MOST (more than 50%) of the Americans don't care about WMD
and even some liberals don't care anymore. The pretext for the war
was not important, the important thing is that MOST of the
Americans think the war's a good thing and has made the world
safer. Time to shut up my liberal mouth and just agree with MOST
of the Americans.
\_ You can try asking some of your Dubya-voting friends
whether they think Iraq had WMDs. My guess is the majority will
say they're now in Syria, buried in the sand somewhere in Iraq
perhaps never to be found, or Saddam just destroyed them right
before the invasion.
\_ I think that's what Safire says. As I recall, as of a few
weeks ago, he's still convinced they'll turn up. If they're
right, I just hope they don't "turn up" when some construction
worker's backhoe busts through a drum of nerve gas.
\_ yes exactly I have 2 Reddie friends and that's what they say
the problem arguing with them is that you can't prove them
wrong.
\_ One wonders why you are so sure yourself.
\_ I am not sure of myself, but I know that asking
someone to disprove something that is not falsifiable
is the sure mark of an idiot.
\_ No, most Americans think the Iraq war was a mistake and
not worth the cost in lives and treasure:
http://www.pollingreport.com/iraq.htm
At best, you can claim 50% for your case, at worst only
30%.
At best, you can claim 50% for your case, but the truth
is, when asked the critical question "Was the war worth
fighting" only 42% say yes. So you are losing the hearts
and minds in the US as well as Iraq.
\_ If the question were, "Was it the right thing to do to
send troops into Iraq", I bet your results would flip.
Choice of words is important in polling questions.
\_ I bet it wouldn't. Do you have any evidence of this
claim, or are you just wishing that it is so?
Read the results for the question "Do you think the
Iraq war has [made America safer]" Only 51%. |
| 5/19 |
|
| www.pollingreport.com/iraq.htm India 10 Iran Iraq 11 Israel 12 Korea 13 Japan 14 Liberia 15 Mexico 16 Northern Ireland 17 Pakistan 18 Russia 19 Saudi Arabia 20 Serbia/Yugoslavia/Kosovo 21 Vietnam Iraq All data are from nationwide surveys of Americans 18 & older. Worth Fighting Not Worth Fighting No Opinion % % % 5/5-6/04 49 47 5 4/15-18/04 51 47 2 3/4-7/04 52 44 3 2/10-11/04 48 50 2 1/15-18/04 56 41 3 12/18-21/03 59 39 2 12/14/03 53 42 5 11/12-16/03 52 44 4 10/26-29/03 54 44 2 10/9-13/03 54 44 2 9/10-13/03 61 37 2 9/4-7/03 54 42 4 8/20-24/03 57 37 5 7/9-10/03 57 40 3 6/18-22/03 64 33 3 4/27-30/03 70 27 4 . Does Does Not No Opinion % % % 5/5-6/04 38 57 5 4/15-18/04 45 53 2 3/4-7/04 43 53 3 12/18-21/03 48 47 5 10/9-13/03 42 53 5 9/10-13/03 42 55 2 . Bogged Down Good Progress No Opinion % % % 5/5-6/04 60 35 5 4/15-18/04 59 41 0 . Very Closely Some- what Closely Not Too Closely Not Closely At All No Opinion % % % % % 5/5-6/04 36 39 16 8 1 . Approve Disap- prove No Opinion % % % 5/5-6/04 48 35 17 . Isolated Wide- spread No Opinion % % % 5/5-6/04 62 31 7 . Quickly Enough Too Slowly No Opinion % % % 5/5-6/04 42 42 16 . Investigate Cover It Up No Opinion % % % 5/5-6/04 44 43 13 . Resign Keep His Job No Opinion % % % 5/5-6/04 20 69 11 . What's your own personal reaction to the apparent abuse of Iraqi prisoners? Not Concerned Concerned, Not Upset Upset, Not Angry Angry No Opinion % % % % % 5/5-6/04 7 39 27 24 2 . Not a Big Deal A Big Deal No Opinion % % % 5/5-6/04 28 69 3 Gallup Poll. Approve Disap- prove No Opinion % % % 5/2-4/04 42 55 3 4/16-18/04 48 49 3 3/26-28/04 51 47 2 1/29 - 2/1/04 46 53 1 1/2-5/04 61 36 3 12/5-7/03 50 47 3 11/3-5/03 45 54 1 10/6-8/03 47 50 3 9/8-10/03 51 47 2 8/25-26/03 57 41 2 7/25-27/03 60 38 2 7/18-20/03 57 39 4 7/7-9/03 58 39 3 6/12-15/03 63 34 3 4/14-16/03 76 21 3 3/29-30/03 71 27 2 3/24-25/03 71 26 3 3/14-15/03 56 41 3 1/31 - 2/2/03 54 42 4 1/3-5/03 55 40 5 12/02 55 39 6 10/02 52 40 8 . Worth Going To War Not Worth Going To War No Opinion % % % 5/2-4/04 50 47 3 4/16-18/04 52 46 2 4/5-8/04 50 47 3 3/26-28/04 56 41 3 3/5-7/04 55 43 2 1/29 - 2/1/04 49 49 2 1/9-11/04 59 38 3 12/15-16/03 65 33 2 12/5-7/03 59 39 2 11/14-16/03 56 42 2 11/3-5/03 54 44 2 10/24-26/03 54 44 2 10/6-8/03 55 44 1 9/19-21/03 50 48 2 9/8-10/03 58 40 2 8/25-26/03 63 35 2 7/25-27/03 63 34 3 7/18-20/03 63 35 2 6/27-29/03 56 42 2 4/14-16/03 73 23 4 4/9/03 76 19 5 4/7-8/03 67 30 3 3/24-25/03 68 29 3 1/3-5/03 53 42 5 . Very Well Moder- ately Well Moder- ately Badly Very Badly No Opinion % % % % % 5/2-4/04 4 33 32 30 1 4/5-8/04 5 30 31 33 1 3/5-7/04 9 46 28 15 2 11/3-5/03 4 34 34 27 1 10/6-8/03 6 36 34 24 - 9/8-10/03 6 41 31 21 1 8/25-26/03 6 44 30 19 1 7/25-27/03 10 46 28 15 1 7/18-20/03 6 48 30 15 1 6/27-29/03 5 51 29 13 2 5/30 - 6/1/03 11 59 22 7 1 CBS News/New York Times Poll. Approve Disap- prove Don't Know % % % ALL 41 52 7 Republicans 77 18 5 Democrats 15 79 6 Independents 37 53 10 Trend: 3/30 - 4/1/04 44 49 7 3/10-14/04 49 43 8 2/24-27/04 46 47 7 2/12-15/04 49 45 6 1/12-15/04 48 46 6 12/21-22/03 57 36 7 12/14-15/03 59 35 6 11/10-12/03 48 48 4 10/20-21/03 49 45 6 9/28 - 10/1/03 47 48 5 9/15-16/03 46 47 7 8/11-12/03 57 33 10 7/03 58 32 10 5/03 72 20 8 3/26-27/03 69 27 4 3/24/03 71 24 5 3/23/03 75 22 3 3/22/03 72 23 5 3/20-21/03 69 25 6 3/15-16/03 55 41 4 3/7-9/03 51 42 7 3/4-5/03 54 39 7 2/24-25/03 52 44 4 2/10-12/03 53 42 5 . Better Worse No Effect Don't Know % % % % 4/23-27/04 10 71 10 9 . Worth It Not Worth It Don't Know % % % 4/23-27/04 33 58 9 3/30 - 4/1/04 37 54 9 3/10-14/04 42 51 7 2/24-27/04 42 52 6 2/12-15/04 41 50 9 1/12-15/04 43 51 6 12/21-22/03 42 47 11 12/14-15/03 44 49 7 11/10-12/03 40 51 9 10/20-21/03 42 52 6 9/28 - 10/1/03 41 53 6 9/15-16/03 43 47 10 8/26-28/03 46 46 8 8/11-12/03 46 45 9 . Iraq was a threat to the United States that required immediate military action. Required Immediate Action Could Have Been Contained Not a Threat At All Don't Know % % % % 4/23-27/04 32 48 17 3 3/10-14/04 42 45 12 1 2/24-27/04 40 46 12 2 2/12-15/04 39 43 15 3 12/21-22/03 44 39 14 3 12/14-15/03 44 37 15 4 7/03 43 43 9 5 6/03 53 35 10 2 . Did Right Thing Should Have Stayed Out Don't Know % % % ALL 47 46 7 Republicans 80 15 5 Democrats 24 69 7 Independents 44 47 9 Trend: 3/30 - 4/1/04 55 39 6 3/10-14/04 58 37 5 2/24-27/04 54 39 7 2/12-15/04 58 37 5 12/21-22/03 62 34 4 12/14-15/03 63 31 6 . Tried Hard Enough Too Quick Don't Know % % % 4/23-27/04 34 61 5 . On Its Own Bring in the UN Don't Know % % % 4/23-27/04 17 76 7 5/03 34 61 5 . Entire Truth Hiding Something Mostly Lying Don't Know % % % % 4/23-27/04 20 56 20 4 . Has a Clear Plan Does Not Don't Know % % % 4/23-27/04 32 58 10 12/14-15/03 34 53 13 11/10-12/03 31 60 9 . Less Than 1 Year 1 to 2 Years 2 to 5 Years More Than 5 Years Don't Know % % % % % 4/23-27/04 8 27 33 25 7 . Stay as Long as It Takes Turn Over Control ASAP Don't Know % % % 4/23-27/04 46 46 8 12/14-15/03 56 35 9 11/10-12/03 49 43 8 . Increased Decreased Same Don't Know % % % % 4/23-27/04 41 18 39 2 10/20-21/03 26 21 51 2 9/15-16/03 25 17 55 3 8/26-28/03 32 19 48 1 5/03 34 15 49 2 . Yes No Don't Know % % % 4/23-27/04 39 51 10 3/30 - 4/1/04 36 47 17 9/28 - 10/1/03 43 42 15 5/03 52 38 11 4/11-13/03 53 38 9 4/2-3/03 53 34 13 3/03 45 40 15 2/03 42 42 16 9/02 51 33 16 Pew Research Center for the People & the Press survey conducted by Princeton Survey Research Associates. Approve Disap- prove Don't Know % % % 4/21-25/04 44 48 8 4/1-4/04 40 53 7 1/6-11/04 59 37 4 9/17-22/03 52 40 8 . Right Wrong Don't Know % % % 4/21-25/04 54 37 9 4/1-4/04 57 35 8 3/17-21/04 55 39 6 2/24-29/04 60 32 8 2/11-16/04 56 39 5 1/6-11/04 65 30 5 12/19/03 - 1/4/04 62 28 10 12/15-17/03 67 26 7 10/03 60 33 7 9/03 63 31 6 7/14 - 8/5/03 63 30 7 6/20 - 7/2/03 67 24 9 4/10-16/03 74 19 7 4/8-9/03 74 19 7 4/2-7/03 72 20 8 3/28 - 4/1/03 69 25 6 3/25-27/03 74 21 5 3/23-24/03 74 21 5 3/20-22/03 71 22 7 . Very Well Fairly Well Not Too Well Not At All Well Don't Know % % % % % 4/21-25/04 12 43 26 15 4 4/1-4/04 14 43 26 13 4 3/17-21/04 16 45 26 11 2 2/11-16/04 17 46 23 11 3 1/6-11/04 22 51 18 6 3 12/19/03 - 1/4/04 23 47 18 7 5 12/15-17/03 28 47 16 6 3 10/03 16 44 25 11 4 9/03 15 47 26 9 3 7/14 - 8/5/03 19 43 24 11 3 6/20 - 7/2/03 23 52 16 5 4 4/10-16/03 61 32 3 1 3 4/8-9/03 60 32 3 3 2 4/2-7/03 55 37 3 2 3 3/25 - 4/1/03 39 46 8 2 5 . Keep Troops Bring Home Don't Know % % % 4/21-25/04 53 40 7 4/1-4/04 50 44 6 12/19/03 - 1/4/04 63 32 5 10/03 58 39 3 9/03 64 32 4 . Has a Clear Plan Doesn't Have a Clear Plan Don't Know % % % 4/21-25/04 36 54 10 4/1-4/04 32 57 11 12/03 44 45 11 10/03 35 54 11 9/03 32 58 10 . |