9/15 Anyone own a 2004/05 Mercedes E320? Have you had any problems
with it? I noticed that the 2003's have had a lot of issues,
primarily electrical, and overall reliability is down for Mercedes
the past 10 years.
\_ Yes, the E-series has had a lot of issues - check Consumer Reports.
Overall Mercedes reliability has fallen into strictly average
territory, but keep in mind that all automakers have generally
improved their quality. The difference between makes is not
as stark as it once was. The real issue with a Benz is that if
something breaks and you're out of warranty, the replacement
cost is ludicrously high. If you want a super-reliable car,
get a Lexus... though they're not as exciting to drive, IMHO.
\_ Based on all the reliability issues I've read I'm leaning
towards a Lexus, but MB really does know how to make their cars
feel classy (interior/exterior). I test drove both and the
Lexus really does feel like a upscale Toyota (current Toyota
driver). Interested to hear any real-life E-Class '04/05
experiences though.
\_ You might consider a BMW. My '02 540 has been mostly
trouble free, and its styling might appeal more than a
Lexus'. I'd stay away from the i-drive 7's, but the newer
5's are supposed to be nice. You might find this from
JD Power useful. http://www.jdpower.com/pdf/2004055.pdf
\_ Sorry, can't help you with that. I had an SLK and it never
had a single problem, but other than the engine its a completely
different car than the E-series.
\_ My friend's family has a 300D. Got 300K miles on it and it's still
running. Guess MB doesn't make solid cars anymore.
\_ Ah yes, the 300D. The days of that sort of Mercedes are long
gone. I think the last gasp of the bank vault build was the 190E
in the early '90s. Anyone know if this had to do with Daimler
moving a shitload of its manufacturing to the former East
Germany?
\_ According to Consumer Reports, Mercedes has gone A LOT further
down from merely "average". It's now the 2nd LEAST reliable brand
according to their surveys, only Volkswagen being lower. That means
that people driving around Buicks and Hyundais have more reliable
cars. NEVER buy a car without first consulting Consumer Reports
to see if the model you are thinking of buying doesn't have some
red flags associated with it, reliability-wise! I own a 2000
Mercedes E320 ... In the first year there were lots of funky
software/electrical type glitches in the car, but since then the
car has been problem free. Note that the Mercedes ML was rated
the LEAST reliable car in Consumer Reports' survey when it first
came out, which is hard to do given some of the competition
(Chevy Camaro, etc.).
\_ I'd be very careful buying a car in its first model year.
You're just asking for trouble if you do that.
\_ My 2004 Sienna seems fine. (Major redesign this year.) But
then it's a Toyota.
\_ keep in mind though that Hyundai had the biggest _improvement_
in reliability of almost any major manufacturer, and in a very
short period of time. My point that the difference between
makes is much more narrow than it once was is still valid.
And yeah, Benzes are rattle-traps these days. Very stylish
rattle-traps.
\_ Mercedes was the top-rated brand 15 years ago and (like someone
else said) is now one of the worst. The C class and E class
are especially bad. With S, SL, and CL you are still getting a
nice car. Not sure about CLK, SLK, and others. Lexus will be
the most reliable luxury brand, along with Acura. Dunno about
Infiniti. Stay away from Audi. BMW (which I own) isn't as good
as it used to be either, but at least the problems are not
with the engine. Porsche is one of the best. Volvo and Jaguar
seem to be hit and miss. Both are making better cars these
days, but my neighbor hates her Volvo because it overheats and
the dealer can find no reason why it should (lemon!).
\_ Does anyone else wish Acura would make at least SOME RWD
cars? What's with these FWD 5-series knockoffs? NSX doesn't
count as its basically an exotic.
\_ Porsche is one of the best? I once heard that Porsches spend
more time at the mechanic than on the streets. Has it changed?
\_ My sister has owned two Porches. One was a 1978. The
other is a 2003. No problems. One of the highest rated if
you read the mags.
\_ But didn't they rate dead last in the JD Powers initial
quality survey? Something like over 150 problems reported
per 100 vehicles. |