Berkeley CSUA MOTD:Entry 28675
Berkeley CSUA MOTD
 
WIKI | FAQ | Tech FAQ
http://csua.com/feed/
2025/05/24 [General] UID:1000 Activity:popular
5/24    

2003/6/9 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:28675 Activity:very high
6/8     Are Maxtor disk drives reliable?
        \_ No.
          \_ examples? sources? tests?
                \_ http://csua.berkeley.edu/~tom/fireball.jpeg
        \_ I second that no.
        \_ My past two HDs have been Maxtor DiamondMax's (the ultra quiet
           ones). No issues with either. In my limited experience, I've
           had shit luck with Quantum (are they even still around?)
        \_ http://www.storagereview.com
        \_ Maxtor bought Quantum's HD division and sacrificed their own
           DiamondMax for Quantum's Fireball line (on the SCSI they also
           chose Quantum's Atlas line).
        \_ Not really.  At my job I maintain about 3/4s of a gazillion TB. I
           replace a lot of maxtor drives.  I hardly ever replace scsi or FC
           drives except Fujitsu which I don't allow in my machines anymore.
           In general IDE drives are not reliable, period.  Get what you pay
           for in the data storage world.  All drives will break at the least
           convenient time.  That's what raid is for.
           \_ For those interested, IBM bought Fujitsu a short time ago.  I
              don't know if it's just Fujitsu's IDEs or if IBM's using all
              Fujitsu all the time.
              \_ actually you got that backwards. IBM sold it's storage
                 business / division to Fujitsu. Fujitsu now manufactures
                 and sells what were IBM drives (such as the Deskstar and
                 TravelStar). That's why IBM is using Fujitsu drives...
                 So now for the most part, Maxtor is Quantum and Fujitsu
                 is IBM.
                 \_ BZZT.  Wrong.  IBM sold it to hitachi. -jon
                    \_ sorry, yes. jon wins. fatality
                       \_ Doesn't matter who owns them.  Fujitsu drives suck.
           \_ Thank y'all. Those are good answers -op
2025/05/24 [General] UID:1000 Activity:popular
5/24    

You may also be interested in these entries...
2008/8/4-10 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:50776 Activity:nil
8/4     I went to Fry's for the first time in ages and was surprised to
        see a 1T Seagate HD on sale. I'm still using my 250G and it's
        only 60% full. What the heck do people put on their HD these
        days, porn? I can't imagine why anyone would want to buy a
        1T drive for personal use.
        \_ HDTV.
	...
2007/5/17-19 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:46676 Activity:nil
5/17    My new 750G Seagate HD shows only 698G available. WHAT THE FUCK??
        \_ 750G = 750*10^9 bytes.  Your OS is probably measuring in 2^30 bytes.
           See GiB vs GB
        \_ Also, disk drive manufacturers advertise "raw" storage, while
           your O/S measures usable storage. You lose quite a bit to
           disk label information, metadata and other various things.
	...
2007/1/7-16 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:45525 Activity:nil
1/7     Looking to get an external HD for my mom (not yermom). Fry's has an
        ACOMDATA 250GB USB 2.0 for $70 after rebate, but I see only review on
        teh Intarweb (and it's suspiciously glowing). Any of you fine sodans
        have experience with this product or its ilk? TIA. --erikred
        \_ Seagate has 5 year warranty, I think. However their reliability
           has gone down the drain in the past few years. I have a WD250
	...
2006/11/7-8 [Computer/Rants, Politics/Foreign/Asia/China] UID:45218 Activity:nil
11/7    I just received my 250GB segate HD that is made in China. I've
        had good experience with segate but they were made in
        Singapore. Has anyone been using Segate drives made in China?
        Any issues? It'll suck if my 250G drive would go bad..
        \_ It doesn't matter.  Your drive *will* go bad, it is just a matter
           of when.  Do backups, use raid or mirroring or both.
	...
2006/8/9-11 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:43951 Activity:nil
8/8     I want to replace the 30GB HD in a 1Ghz iBook. Will any notebook HD
        do? Any recommendations? Price/Reliability more important than perf.
        I'm looking at a Hitachi Travelstar or Seagate Momentus from newegg.
        \_ I've used Travelstar's before in a PB, they are fine.
        \_ I went through 2 Travelstars before installing a Seagate.
	...
2006/7/17-19 [Computer/HW/Laptop, Computer/HW/Drives] UID:43698 Activity:nil
7/17    My western digital WD800UE 80gb 5400 RPM laptop HD sometimes
        gives off a few "clicking" noise. Although this has been going
        on for a while and I haven't run into any problems. Is this
        the click of death? Should I be concerned? I am using it in an
        external enclosure and had it shortly after I got it. (it
        started to make that noise when I was trying to "disconnect
	...
2006/5/18-22 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:43088 Activity:nil
5/18    dnm, a friend an occasional denizen of #csua has some hardware for
        sale.  He wanted to make it available to local geeks before
        advertising on craigslist or eBay so I'm posting this for him.
        No prices listed, email dnm with an offer.
        -dans
        * At least 5 HP Vectra VL420 DT desktop boxes, all Pentium 4 1.6 GHz
	...
2005/12/22-23 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:41113 Activity:moderate
12/21   What's the quietest, most reliable 300-500GB HD out there these
        days? I'm mainly concerned with reliability/sound/price per GB
        to store lots of media stuff, and I'm not too concerned about
        performance. Also a related question, when do you guys think
        1T drives will come out, 2008? 2009?
        \_ in my experience, seagate drives tend to be quieter than others
	...
2005/11/16-17 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:40609 Activity:kinda low
11/15   [unrelated to politics] My debian machine at home (I'm learning and
        tinkering) seems to spin the HD down occasionally.  I'd like to never
        spin down the HD (or at least control which hours it can).  Any
        pointers to doing this?
        \_ # apt-get install hdparm
           # hdparm -S 0 /dev/hda
	...
2005/5/12-13 [Computer/HW/Laptop, Computer/SW/Languages/Misc] UID:37652 Activity:kinda low
5/11    If you noticed that your laptop HD never rests because it's doing
        something, and you've already killed all auxilary processes and made
        drives not "Fast Indexable", it's the explorer that's funky. Here
        is one solution. Kill explorer and then run it again. You can use
        a batch file script:
        taskkill -im explorer.exe /f
	...
2005/5/11-12 [Consumer/Audio, Computer/HW/Drives] UID:37625 Activity:nil
5/11    I'd like to be able to use my mp3 player as a rescue os disk as well.
        It shows up as USB HD on most OS.  The mp3 player itself works fine
        as long as I store all of the music on the first vfat partition.  I'd
        like to be able to either install linux onto the HD or store various
        ISO images on the HD and have it boot from it, with menu, so I can
        can select different images.  Anyone know of such method?
	...
2005/5/9-11 [Computer/HW/Drives] UID:37579 Activity:kinda low
5/8     Poll. If you even had to return a HD, what was your experience like?
        \_ Hitachi: Regular RMA, No advanced RMA, test suite sucks
        \_ WD: Had 2 consecutive failures (same model) in 6 months, the RMA
           website is really good, has tracking and advanced RMA. Advanced RMA
           requires you putting in credit card number so that if you don't
           return the defective drive in 30 days they'll charge you. It's not
	...
Cache (4645 bytes)
www.storagereview.com
Wizard launched the SR D2OL distributed computing project. Since then, we've managed to claw our way up to 5th place on the 15 all time list. If we're to climb any further though, we need more help! Just follow 16 these simple instructions to be up, running, and contributing in less than five minutes! The drive's massive 400 GB capacity isn't achieved through an increase in density, however. Rather, it seems that Hitachi has extended the 7K250's architecture up from its maximum of three to five platters, making the 7K400 the first Deskstar to feature a five-platter flagship since, well, the 75GXP. More information may be found in 19 Hitachi's press release. IFRAME: 20 aebfaac1 Fujitsu's Newly-Announced SCSI Drives 08 March 2004 Fujitsu today announced a refresh of both its 10k and 15k RPM SCSI lines, the second step (following Hitachi's announcement of its Ultrastar 10K300) in a long-awaited update in SCSI densities and capacities. The 10,000 MAT series combines up to four platters to yield a flagship capacity of 300 gigabytes while the 15,000 RPM MAU pushes up to 147 GB. Fujitsu will finally incorporate FDB motors across the board, hopefully combining reduced noise levels with the firm's top-rate performance. More information may be found in the 21 manufacturer's press release. Hitachi Global Storage Technologies (formerly IBM storage) is once again first out of the gate, this time offering a 300 GB 10K RPM drive, the Ultrastar 10K300. Like the previous Ultrastar 146Z10, the 10K300 achieves this high capacity by incorporating five rather than the more standard four platters in the flagship unit. The drive incorporates FDB motors, which will hopefully attentuate the line's previous penchant towards very high idle noise levels. Miscellanea 20 February 2004 This week yielded a couple interesting developments on the hard drive front. The benefits, of course, are numerous- lower access times via standardization of smaller platters, less heat and noise due to the physically smaller size, cost savings via both less consumed material and less required physical space to store large arrays of disks, etc. Read more about it in 23 Seagate's official press release. Many readers have noted the distinct lack of advancement (capacity-wise) in the enterprise domain. The traditional fourth quarter of last year, for instance, passed with conspicuous silence as no major new units were announced. A combination of technological hurdles with somewhat tapered-off demand. That said, we're told larger disks in the traditional form-factor will appear this year. On another front, SR has never taken an official stance regarding the IBM Deskstar 75GXP reliability issue. Witness, for example, the amount of posters in both SR's community as well as others decrying a given family or brand based on a single experience. The Raptor Review 28 January 2004 A preview late last year of Western Digital's next-generation Raptor indicated world-class non-server performance coupled with the future promise of competitive server scores through the introduction of tagged command queuing. The WD740GD has hit the channels and been readily available for a bit. FAQ: What's a good benchmark to assess drive performance? At the very least, however, the recently-revised 27 FAQ entry will help you decide which ones to avoid! A Look at the Samsung SpinPoint P80 12 January 2004 The Samsung SpinPoint P80 combines the firm's traditionally quiet operation with contemporary 80-gigabyte density and a (now unique) across-the-board three-year warranty. Does it have what it takes to stack up against the more well-known competition? We've spent the past 36 hours uploading our last daily backup at a painfully slow pace. Most of the data is in place- all site features except the forum (the database of which is having tricky problems with MySQL3) and features that depend on the forum login (the reliability survey and reader polls) should be up and running without a hitch. Importing the forum database is a bit more complicated since RHE3 includes (sigh) MySQL3 while the forum database was powered by MySQL4. Though MySQL's site states that v3 can accept dumps generated by v4 without a hitch, practice, as usual, has been different (Update 3:35 AM: MySQL4 upgrade complete, forums operational). Start your holiday shopping off right by treating yourself or a friend to Western Digital's new Caviar WD2500PB, a combination of the blazing Caviar engineering with long-awaited fluid-dynamic-bearing motors. It's in stock now at SR Sponsor 30 HyperMicro for just $239. Remember to mention SR in your order to receive free UPS ground shipping!