5/19 Exercise advice sought: If I am just trying to tone up a little
can I do something like 400-500 curls with 10lbs dumbells or will
that little weight not do anything? Better to do half as many
with 20lbs? I am a small stature person.
\_ Hi, small stature person!
\_ If you want to bulk up, do enough weight so that you can just
barely do 3 sets of 12. If you just want toning, take yoga.
\_ 2nded. You'll get results more quickly this way, and at 20lbs
you need not fear of turning into that enormous guy at the gym
with hairy shoulders. Just make sure your form is good if
you're just starting off w/ weights.
\_ tone != bulk. If you want tone and definition, you do want more
reps with lower weight. Try 3-5 sets of 15-20 reps. More reps
per set if you like.
\_ That is why I asked if 400x10lbs or 200x20lbs would be
better.
\_ You should never need to do 400 or even 200 reps (I hope
you're just giving exagerrated numbers for effect). The
above poster is right... find a weight where you can just
barely do 20 or even 25 reps and work from there. Oh, and
something that gets lost in the equation of toning/bulking:
diet. You can have the perfect workouts, with the ideal
weights, sets, reps, exercises, form, etc., but it won't
that the hard way (yes, I've been improvement once I cut
down on the french fries)
make a difference until you start eating right. I learned
that the hard way (yes, I've seen improvement after I cut
out the fast food)
\_ Don't listen to these people who haven't tried it! I would
recommend 800-1000 curls with 5 lbs, I have had very
effective results with that. Try it for yourself!
\_ Sounds like a recipie for tendonitis. Curls, like most
weight work, isolates a particular muscle group. Unlike
exercizes that impact a larger number of muscles, weight
work is not suitable for rep counts. There is debate over
whether the 30-rep sets are safe. Even the high-rep clique
at the gym would agree that 800 is crazy.
\- I dont claim to have a particularly sane exercise program
but some comments: 1. first i think doing a few hundred
curls of low weight should be ok. it is probably like using
a rowing machine for 20-30 min. 2. if you goal is tone and
general fitness with a low target and without joining a gym
or buying pricey equipment, then i'd just run like 3miles
3-4 times a week. that moves large muscles unlike the curl
program and will probably burn more calories and get your
mtabolism up and your fat level down. if you ear a reasonable
mtabolism up and your fat level down. if you eat a reasonable
amount of protein, it is easy to bulk up arms for men. legs
are a lot more work. --psb
\_ The problem is that with any serious weight and crazy high
repetitions, it's very possible to give yourself a RSI. This
is especially true if you have no idea what you're doing and
have little or no idea of good form. This is a very hard
lesson to learn by injuring yourself.
\_ Isometrics, son. It's all about isometrics.
\_ I don't think you ever need to worry about bulking up
unintentionally. If it was that easy to get big, you wouldn't
see people spending 24x7 in the gym, drinking protein shakes,
taking supplements, and reading muscle magazines. Start with
a standard excercise routine which you can find in any excercise
book or web page and if you notice yourself getting "too big",
cut back on the weight and increase your reps/sets by 15%. -emin
\_ Here's a question. Why do any of this? Simply to look better? I
can think of a dozen kinds of exercise that will keep you in shape
and certainly sound more enjoyable than endless reps in a gym or
some room in one's house. I suppose I need to give partha credit for
hinting at the same point. I swim about a mile a day and I'll bet,
if nothing else, I have more interesting things to look at. :)
\- i sort of got addicted to swimming for a while and was swimming
maybe 10-12 miles a week. i dont think swimming gets you very
far unless you have a lot of discipline [i.e. you do the
equivalent of running intervals] or you combine with weights.
if you do the equivalent of a slow jog in the pool, it doesnt
get you very far. if i am totally out of shape then i start
my aerobic conditioning by swimming, since it's hard to get
motvated to run if you cant even run 2 miles. but otherwise
swimming alone to me is like exercise bike or walking ... for
old people or people who for some other reason, e.g. 50lbs
overweight, cant run or something like that. --psb |