1/18 So I have a cable modem and both a Debian Linux and a WinXP
machine. I want to set up one as the firewall/server for my
internal network to the internet. Which is preferable and why?
\_ obLinuxSux! & obDoesntWorkWithCableModem.
Seriously, I'd pick linux since its possible to secure it
to some extent (unless you really need asp and vbscript
in which case you are stuck with XP).
\_ Clueless n00b. You can run asp, etc through the linux firewall.
\_ Dipshit, I know you can port forward, but he said
he wants a single fw/server. If that is the case
then he is stuck with xp. And if he wants vb, asp
etc, he is also stuck with iis.
\_ Do a little research on reverse web proxies (specifically
URL based proxying)
\_ good thing all the politics threads got deleted,
so we can have intelligent technical dialog like
this.
\_ I'd do linux if you already have it. It doesn't really need any
resources (P100 is fine) and if you don't play with it, will be
up for 3-6 months at a time (it's a cheap PC, so you'll probably
have some hardware failure or trip over the cord every so often.)
\_ or if you were lazy and had about $75, you could buy NAT-in-a-box
like a Linksys cable router/firewall, but then accessing your
linux box would be a bit trickier, if you needed to get at it
from the "outside".
\_ you can get one on craigslist for ~$40
\_ Or you could pay an extra $5/month and get a real IP for both.
Using pf on openbsd and both winroute and zone alarm 2.x on w2k
each with own public IP. As far as I know, nothing ugly has
happened after 2+ years like this. Script kiddies run into the
fw's on both *all* the time but nothing serious is going on. |