1/8 stupid question: i just finished reading the Trilogy, and i don't
get what the two towers are. clearly one of them is Orthanc, saruman's
tower, but what is the other one? Sauron semems to have several
towers, and I think Gondor has a tower or two. Aren't there towers
all over middle earth? what the hell? is it Barad Dur?
\_ I recall reading that it is a reference to Orthanc and Minas Tirith.
-- ulysses
\_ minas ithil and minas arnor. - someone who read the Silmarion.
\_ It's yermom's twin towers. They always come in pairs.
\_ They don't come in paris in the movie Kung Pao.
\_ I think Minas Tirith and Minas Ithil (renamed Minas Morgul). --dim
\_ It's just a metaphore.
\_ Minas Tirith and Minas Ithil (renamed Minas Morgul) for the
opposition of light and dark, but the two in the book are
Cirith Ungol (Barad-dur) and Orthanc. Tolkien himself was unhappy
\_ I think Cirith Ungol != Barad-dur. The first is the orc fortress
a bit ambiguous. --dim
guarding the pass (the stairs of Cirith Ungol) and the other is
the great fortress in the plains of Gorgoroth and the center of
Sauron's power. I don't have the book with me, though.
\_ You are right. --dim
\_ ...and this was the source of my confusion. Barad dur
seems more important, because the Main Evil Dude lives
there, but on the other hand, we never actually see
barad dur in the story, unlike cirith ungol, which
is pretty important. thanks for providing the only
useful or intelligent answer! -OP
with the title because of the ambiguity. I quote: "I am not happy
at all about the title 'The Two Towers'." It is supposed to be
a bit ambiguous. It can even be Orthanc and Minas Morgul. --dim
\_ Found this:
http://members.cts.com/king/e/erikt/tolkien/2towers.htm
-- ulysses
the problem is that the 2 towers can refer to anything DEPENDING on
what books you've read. Hell, even the hobbit has Dol Guldur (in
mirkwood, sauron's 1st attempt to set up power)... If you read the
silmarion, it's obvious you're talking about minas *. if you read
lotr, then it's maybe barad-dur and minas tirith. Altho rohas is
just as important. Btw: 3 rings for the elven kings went to:
1. elrond, 2. galadriel, and 3, (Narya the Great) went to Cirdan who
gave it to Gandalf.
\_ Narya the Great? I suppose the others are Nenya the Okay and
Vilya the Adequate... |