11/13 When I was in grade school, one year a new kid from Florida joined
our class. The only thing I remember about him is that he was taught
that pi = 3. This was 5th or 6th grade. -N'04!
\_ Actually, many physicists use 3 for pi and 10 for g when doing
quick calculations. For the most part, calculations are
considered legit if they're within an order of magnitude.
\_ the most severe case of this is theoretical astrophysics. usually
they let pi, the speed of light, planks constant and a slew of
other constants be one so they can just focus on the *form*
of the equations. it all depends on what you're trying to do.
i'd much rather have someone use 3 or 3.1 and know why that's
ok in a certain situation than use 3.141592653589793238 for
finding the area of a circular birthday cake ten inches across
and not understand why that's pointless. of course this has
nothing to do with the above post, but i think it's an
important issue appropos of the proliferation of calculators
in classrooms today.
\_ speed of light = 1, okay, that just involves changing your
measurement units. But pi = 1? So it mever causes problem
when the circumference of a circle is as long as its diameter?
\_ Usually, they don't let p or h (h bar) or some of the other
constants equal 1, they just lump them together as a constant
factor. The only value I've seen set to one is c. ----ranga
\_ I don't think they were calculating stellar distances or
looking for the form of the equation in my former classmate's
Florida 4th grade classroom. |