4/19 ME question. What is the difference between an engine of different
styles but of the same volume displacement. Like, what is the
difference between a 3.0 liter inline-4 and a 3.0 liter inline-6.
How is 6 cylinder better than 4 in terms of performance and
efficiency? Same question for a 3.0 liter inline-6 vs. a 3.0
liter V-6.
\_ The smaller the engine, the more efficient. The larger the engine,
the more powerful. Therefore the most efficient engine doesn't
exist and the most powerful would fill the universe.
\_ More cylinders == higher revving. Fewer cylinders == more torque.
\_ ???? The Honda S2000 is a 4 cylinder that revs very very high.
What are you smoking ? -eric
\_ Fewer cylinders does NOT give you more torque.
\_ For the same engine size, it tends to. Look at twin bikes.
\_ RIDE BIKE!
\_ and where do valves come in?
\_ In the engine compartment, normally installed at factory.
\_ This is all wrong. Fewer cylidners means higher revving because
there is less rotational mass in the camshaft, valve lifters, etc.
4 vs. 6 vs. 8 and inline vs. V refers to the stagger of the pistons
and firing orders, etc. So you get different power strokes per
rotation of the cam. The 8 will be smoother and deliver more
power strokes per rotation. The 4 can produce similar power but
demands higher RPMs to do so. If you had an inline 8, then the
camshaft would lift 2 cylinders at a time, in 45 degree increments
which means any 2 would be at the bottom, half-up, half-down, and
about to fire...it makes no sense. You could fire 4 together but
there would be a long compression stroke with no power delivery.
This is the kind of stuff that V, inline, 4, 6, 8 determines...
Not horsepower. Horsepower is purely determined by the surface
area of the piston getting shoved down...the bigger the piston,
the better except for mass and interia...it all balances out. |