|
7/9 |
2004/3/22-23 [Politics/Foreign/MiddleEast/Israel] UID:12794 Activity:high |
3/22 Blow me, MOTD censor dickwit. I posted a perefctly "legit" link, not that it's your job to judge. As I said, cool shit: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/3556099.stm -John \_ Blind, paralyzed 67 year old man, confined to a wheelchair, assassinated by missles fired from a helicopter. Reason: he was a threat to Israel's security. \_ Why didn't Israel just arrest him? \_ They were trolling the motd. \_ Oooh, good troll. No bites, though, troll harder! \_ then why you kept erasing my post? \_ John, killing him is not going to solve the problem. Elimate Hamas is not going to resolve the problem. You do need to carry out genocide on Palestinian people, reduce their population to insignificant number (similiar to the native American in USA) to solve that problem... if you want to solve th problem using violence. \_ "The problem" is intractable. There is no solution that doesn't involve the destruction of Israel or moving a few million Arabs from Gaza and the WB into other Arab countries that don't want the black sheep of Islam. \_ Why stop at Gaza and the WB? Why is that going to be enough? There will be no peace for Israel until every living Arab is exterminated. \_ No cookie. Sorry. Maybe you'll catch me in a foul mood some other time and I'll feed you then. I just had a 3 hour lunch so you're not getting fed today. \_ Wow, for a bunch peace loving people who just want equal rights the Palestinians sure were broken up about the death of that mass murderer... \_ He incited violence. He didn't murder anyone. While inciting violence is a crime. It's nothing near being a capital offence. The fact that Israel is assassinating people for their political ranting shows that neither side has any moral legitimacy in this conflict. \_ so did Hitler, he just ordered people killed \_ That's all fine and dandy in your highly controlled and very law and order western society. This is a war, not a civil disobedience issue. Do you think we should send the FBI to arrest bin Laden, too? Some people are beyond the law especially in places where there is no law. He was the law. \_ They did arrest him and put him in prison for 8 years. Then they let him go for some reason. Why did they release him if he's so dangerous? \_ Because Israel is still a law abiding western society and the current 'war' hadn't started yet. It was a time of relative quiet and the palestinians hadn't stuck the knife in yet. \_ Hamas is a social organization that brings food to the poor, educates children, provides jobs to the jobless and brings hope to the hopeless in a war torn area in a fight the people didn't ask for. The man is a martyr and a victim. How can you not see the good that Hamas does for the people? The poor guy was in a wheel chair? How could he be responsible for anyone's death? This was an unjustified, cowardly act, very unlikely to achieve peace in the area and very very bad news for the Middle East peace process. The only way to stop the violence is for the Israelis to stop killing Palestinian children, women, and old crippled men with their American build missiles and leave *all* of the Palestinian territories. We must go back to the pre-1947 lines. Violence only begets violence, so the next time a bunch of Israeli teens get killed at a pizza parlor, disco, or a university cafeteria by a Palestinian martyr, they should know they've brought this upon themselves. For every Palestinian victim of Israeli aggression and illegal occupation there should be a thousand Israeli children killed on buses, in school and out on the town. Once the Jews are driven into the sea, there shall finally be peace in the Middle East and then we can look to bringing the same peace to Europe, starting with France and Spain. \_ Yassin has stated in several interviews that he supports suicide attacks on Israeli civilians. Here's one with Die Welt: http://tinyurl.com/24t5m and one with the BBC: http://tinyurl.com/2by97 -John \_ It's kinda disturbing when the greatest dreams parents can think of for their children is to become human bombs. \_ Golda Meir, "we will have peace when palestinian mothers love their children more than they hate Jews." \_ thanks for illustrating what the attitude problem is. You are blind. One does not need to build a bomb with his own hands to be responsible for leading others to do the actual work. You say 'violence begets violence', but yet you do not equally condemn the Palestinians for killing. Almost every cease fire, or peace accord, is broken by yet another suicide bomber, who believes there should be no negotiation, just unilateral withdrawl. For every one, you claim blood of a thousand. Where is the equality in that? With that statement, you imply a belief in the superiority of one group over another. You'd fit well alongside the Nazis. I'm all for a separate Palestinian state, and I dislike a lot of Israel's actions and responses, but I can't say the Palestinians aren't part of the problem either. \_ I call Godwin's Law on you. \_ Pay attention to the next cease fire. It will probably be broken by an Isreali attack, just like the last one was. Sharon is no more interested in peace than Hamas is. \_ No, pay attention to the past. Once you see who started the last few years worth of terrorism and upped the ante with suicide bombers you'll start to understand why the Israelis do what they do. If you were allowed to settle the issue, what would you do? Tell Israel to go back to pre-67 borders? Close all the check points and give free and open access to the entire country to every Palestinian? \_ On the other hand, Israel has been continously creating new settlements settling Joos from all over the world coming back to Israel on Palestinian land. \_ I disagree with the current settlement policy, however that is not the root cause of the arabs sending their own children into civilian crowds wearing bombs. \_ I'm pretty sure that was satire man. \_ Yeah. He had me going up until that disco line. \_ disco? that was the tip off? so you're unaware of how many Israeli teens were killed in the last 2-3 years in Israeli discos? sigh...like pearls.... \_ No, silly boy, the tip off was the part where the author said that Israeli teens getting blown up in discos should realize that they'd brought it upon themselves. Of course, you'd rather curse the darkness than light a candle, I understand why you jumped to that conclusion. \_ Problem is, there are people who honestly think this \_ there was a time when Muslim world are the heaven for Jews who are escaping prosecution from Christian church. I wonder how many people remember that. \_ was that before or after mass conversions to Islam by the sword? \_ after _and_ before. after the North African conversion by the sword and before the fanatics came to power in Iberia. \_ so the ones who didn't get killed or forced to convert found Islam a haven of open mindedness? cool. \_ willful child. they mostly emigrated to Islamic kingdoms after the mass conversions and before the rise of the fanatics. many of them immigrated when the latter came to power. \_ When was this period "before the rise of fanatics"? The whole religion started on day one that way. \_ Nice and glib, but you're completely ignoring the Islamic Renaissance of the late first Milennium. Go visit a place called a "library" and read some interesting things called "books" before posting anything else. \_ Islamic Renaissance? hahaha. they are still living in the dark ages twink \_ Are you trying to look stupid? \_ No, he's accurate and the truth hurts. The IR is a period of time they were advancing faster than Europe in terms of technology and math but they were still religious fanatics, primitives, and incredibly barbaric by our western standards today. They never left the middle ages. They still whine about 500+ year 'transgressions' by countries and people that don't even exist anymore. \_ 500+ years? That's nothing. Jews claim right to a land they left 2000 years ago. \_ I am not sure that "open mindedness" is the right word, but Jews were treated better in the Ottoman Empire than in Christian Europe. \_ The word you are looking for is 'expediency.' The Ottomans knew that tolerance was the only way to run a multi-ethnic, multi-religious, multi- cultural state (which included that haven of tranquility, the Balkans). -- ilyas \_ Is it bad to be tolerant for the sake of expediency? Is Putin's being tough a stance of principle? \_ I wasn't making a value judgement. Also, you can't argue with results. -- ilyas \_ how does the ottomans compare with the russians on their treatment of jews historically? \_ The jews were always persecuted in Russia (Czarist and Communist). The word 'pogrom' is a Russian word. Email me for a longer account if you are interested. -- ilyas \_ they did try to genocide the christian armenians though. \_ Your point is valid, but your use of the word is not. s/genocide/commit genocide against/ \_ I realize that, but I think we should allow it to be used as a verb or invent a verb version. maybe genocize. ethnically cleanse is awkward, exterminate is possible but not specific enough. "commit genocide against" is too long, and I am lazy. \_ You want a verb form of a word made up to evoke moral outrage and loathing because the alternatives are too long and you are lazy? This truly is the end of the Roman Empire. \_ what's the big deal? this happens all the time. eg. "google" is now used as a verb. \_ The big deal is that google is not synonymous with death and misery. Genocide is. \_ I don't see the relevancy of "death and misery" to the argument. |
7/9 |
|
news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/3556099.stm Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, spiritual head of Palestinian militant group Hamas, has been killed in an Israeli air strike. He was targeted as he returned from a mosque in Gaza City at daybreak. The killing triggered unrest and calls for revenge from Palestinians, as tens of thousands took part in a funeral. Hamas said Israel had opened the gates of hell - but the army said the Sheikh had been personally responsible for the killing of Israelis. Security forces killed the Hamas leader in an air strike on his car in northern Gaza Strip, an army statement said. Reports from the scene said Sheikh Yassin was being pushed in his wheelchair when he was directly hit by a missile. Two bodyguards and one of Sheikh Yassins sons were reported to be among those killed. At the funeral procession in Gaza City, mourners jostled to touch Sheikh Yassins coffin, which was draped in a green Hamas flag. The battle is open and war between us and them is open, said senior Hamas leader Abdul Aziz al Rantissi. Israeli Deputy Defence Minister Zeev Boim said Yassin had been behind a terror network in Gaza and was what he called marked for death. Grief and anger After news of the killing broke crowds took to the streets in Gaza, denouncing Israel and calling for revenge. The protests quickly spread to other Palestinian areas, and clashes broke out between youths and Israeli soldiers. A Palestinian journalist was killed by troops while covering a protest in the West Bank town of Nablus, Palestinian sources say. Three other protesters were reported to have been killed in separate incidents, but Israeli sources have not confirmed any of the deaths. Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat has declared three days of mourning. The BBCs David Chazan in Gaza says the grief and anger is not limited to Hamas supporters, and further attacks and suicide bombings appear inevitable. In the first reaction from the US, the State Department appealed for calm. UK Foreign Secretary Jack Straw said the killing of an elderly man in a wheelchair was unjustified and very unlikely to achieve its objective. France also condemned the assassination, and European Union foreign policy chief Javier Solana said it was very, very bad news for the Middle East peace process. Cycle of violence Palestinian Prime Minister Ahmed Qurei called the attack on Sheikh Yassin a dangerous, cowardly act. Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat told the BBC: This will add fuel to the fire, and the cycle of violence and counter-violence. He said the only way to stop violence was to end the occupation of Palestinian territories. Israeli Finance Minister Binyamin Netanyahu said that even if a harsh response from Hamas was likely, the long-term effect of the killing will be to rein in militants because their leaders will know that they will be destroyed. Military sources told the BBC the attack on Sheikh Yassin was personally organised and directed by Mr Sharon. At a cabinet meeting last week, formal authorisation was given to attack and kill specific targets Israel says were responsible for the twin suicide attack in the port of Ashdod on 14 March that killed 10 Israelis. The BBCs Wyre Davies in Jerusalem says the decision to target such a high-profile figure is a significant move and Israel is likely to be on high alert in expectation of a response from Hamas. Israel has warned on many occasions that it would target the Hamas chief after the militant group killed scores of Israelis. A few months ago, they narrowly missed him after firing on a house where he had been having lunch with fellow Hamas members a short while earlier. Israel sealed off the West Bank and Gaza Strip after the killing, barring Palestinians from entering the Jewish state. |
tinyurl.com/24t5m -> backspin.typepad.com/backspin/2003/11/sheik_yassin_in.html From the Wild File Main Palestinian Pez Tuesday, November 25, 2003 Sheik Yassin Interview Blogger Stefan Sharkansky translated an interview that the German paper Die Welt did with Sheik Ahmed Yassin, the Hamas head who is often referred to in the press as Hamas spiritual leader. Weve copied the translated interview and Sharkanskys commentary below. One lowlight: Sheik Yassin hadnt even heard about last weeks terror attacks in Istanbul. DIE WELT: What is the goal of the negotiations in Cairo that the Palestinian factions were invited to? I only know that it concerns forming a joint Palestinian position. DIE WELT: A joint Hudna ceasefire or a joint escalation of the struggle? Yassin: Without an Israeli withdrawal there can be no discussion of a cessation in the struggle. DIE WELT: Are there any discussions in government circles about a long-term ceasefire? Yassin: All the Palestinian groups and the Egyptians will be taking part in the talks. Arent these the points on which Israeli Prime Minister Sharon announced unilateral steps? And as long as the soldiers are here next to us and as long as there are assassinations, there can be no talk of calming the situation. Yassin: Not without clear concessions from the Israelis concerning the settlements and the restoration of our Palestinian rights. For a full understanding of Hamas definition of Palestinian rights, be sure to read the Hamas Charter DIE WELT: Can there be an inter-Palestinian agreement? Yassin: We reached an accommodation when Mahmud Abbas came into office. His only wish the last time we met was that the dialogue would continue. DIE WELT: And what is the substance of this inter-Palestinian dialogue? Qureia also wants the settlements to be evacuated and for the assassinations to stop. DIE WELT: Youre sitting here in your own home after several weeks of hiding underground. Which ultimately only shows how vulnerable we are to their attacks. DIE WELT: Does that mean that you will carry out more bombings in Israel? As long as Palestinian civilians are victims of Israeli attacks, then Israeli civilians will also be victims. His advisors tell him about the attacks on synagogues and British institutions in Turkey. He shakes his head in astonishment: The murder of Jews and Christians, who stay as guests under Islamic protection, I cannot support. Yassin: I know neither the objectives nor the identity of the attackers. If it wasnt already clear before reading this interview, the root causes of the Palestinian problem are a the Sheikh Yassins of this world believe its their God-given duty to kill Jews and Christians until they agree to live as guests under Islamic protection; |
tinyurl.com/2by97 -> news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/3224989.stm I asked him about the burning topic of the day, a possible Palestinian ceasefire. Hamas has agreed to hold truce talks with the Palestinian Authority, but Sheikh Yassin said it was still waiting to hear the terms. The issue is where the Palestinian national interest is in all of this, he said. In the past we declared a unilateral ceasefire, we gave the Israeli enemy a truce for 50 days, but they did not commit to it even for one day. They continued with their killings and crimes, with demolishing houses and building settlements. So we have to study where the national interest lies: with resistance, or with declaring a ceasefire. Military battle Hamas has been calling for a mutual ceasefire, one that would mean an end to Israeli assassinations and incursions as well as Palestinian attacks. Judging by public statements, Palestinian officials have also adopted that approach. I asked Sheikh Yassin if Hamas would be willing to stop suicide bombings inside Israel. Such attacks have killed hundreds of civilians and led to international condemnation of the Islamic movement. On the ground they have also brought harsh Israeli retaliation and threats to expel the Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat. Our battle is a military one, against soldiers and Jewish settlers. The attacks inside Israel, these are operations we carry out in response to Israeli crimes against our people, Sheikh Yassin replied, repeating Hamas long-standing policy towards suicide attacks. They are not the strategy of our movement, our strategy is to defend ourselves against an occupying army, and against the settlers and the settlements. Sheikh Yassin said recent talks between Hamas and Hezbollah in Lebanon were not about military co-operation, as Israel charges. He said the two groups were talking about a prisoner exchange Israel is currently negotiating with the Lebanese militia. State aid But he also indicated there was potential for greater political co-ordination between Palestinian militant groups and those in Lebanon and Iraq, because of Americas increasingly uncritical support for Israel. Americas interests cannot be separated from Israels interests, they are connected in a powerful way, he said. America is defending Israel in the UN Security Council by vetoing resolutions. We did not fight the Americans, we did not fight the Europeans, we only fought on Palestinian land against the Israeli enemy who took our home. So why have America and Europe put us on the list of terrorists, when we never touched their interests? And why did they hit Iraq under the slogan of weapons of mass destruction? War against Islam He has always said that Hamas fights only against Israel, that the group is not interested in widening the struggle. But now he is suggesting the Middle East conflict may not simply be about Israels occupation of Arab land, it may also be about what he calls Americas war against Islam. When George Bush declared his war on terrorism after 11 September, he said it was a crusaders war, said Sheikh Yassin. And there are voices in America today who also say this is a religious war. And the evidence shows that the war is against Muslims: in Afghanistan, in Iraq, and in Palestine. The Hamas leader seems to be saying to America and Europe that the conditions are there for an ideological conflict, what some would call a clash of civilisations. And although Israel and the West view Sheikh Yassin as an Islamic terrorist, he is also one of the most influential politicians in the Middle East. So many people will take seriously his charge that the regional conflicts may be turning into a religious war. |