9/14 What is the size of US armed forces anyway? I thought US has
more than 300k troops. Aside from cost, why people say US forces
are strech thin?
\_ the more funding you give to the armed forces, the more it'll
spend on war. the more it spends on war, the more money it'll
need. 300K troop is not enough. Neither is 1 million. It's
never enough.
\_ It's the purpose of the armed forces to be prepared for war.
The more they have, they better prepared they can be. This
is common sense to most people. Let's just scrap the entire
military and save a buck. Would that make you happy, comrade?
\_ Political gain.
\_ around 150k forces depolyed in Iraq alone, probably more in Kuwait
to support them, that's a pretty sizeable chunk of that 300k. When
you consider that you need local troops, troops at premenent bases
like in Europe and Japan, well gee, that seems pretty stretched
to me. Add to that the fact that it is an all volenteer army that
has been seeing recruitment and reenlistment rates plumet... see
the problem yet?
\_ There are more than 300k troops. That's a ridiculously small
number so the rest of what you're saying is silly. Also, all
4 branches easily met and exceeded quota since 9/11.
\_ Where do you get your figures for recruitment rates? My
understanding is the army had no problems filling their quotas
after 9/11 (and the very successful baghdad blitz helped).
The army's main problem is money, not men.
\_ I thought they had cash a-plenty, but that a lot of it
was wasted on pork-barrel projects, like the V-22 and
strategically pointless bases, rather than on boring things
like training and spare parts. -John
\_ Different budgets. Lack of spare parts in the US Army
means they can't strip and replace every part on every
M1-A2 active in the field while on the front at the same
time. You'll note the lack of any reports of soldiers
unable to complete missions due to lack of spares.
\_ can they mobilize all the national guards for Iraq,
leaving just skeleton personel for bases in USA, and
throw everyone at Iraq so the situation there could get
stablized more quickly?
\_ They've done that to some degree. All our gate guards
are National Guardspeople at Kirtland AFB, NM. --PeterM
\_ more people won't help in Iraq. They're doing ok in most
of the country. The reports of trouble from Iraq are *all*
from a small section of the country that was always hard
core pro-saddam. Go check a map every time they report an
event. It's always something just north or north west of
baghdad. That's prime we-love-the-president-day real estate.
\_ yea, the rest are all peace loving shiite mullahs, just
like their brothers in Iran.
\_ ~ 2 million for all branches. |