*/* Re: motd, soda, undergrads, community, etc: I can count on a few
fingers the number of times I've logged in to soda in the last year
or two, and half of them were to recover some old files I stored here
from my school days. Why? Because there's no reason to be here for
me. It doesn't matter what the format is: motd, fb, yahoo groups,
whatever. What *purpose* is there, or should there be, to the on-
going existence of this environment? Once you (the generic you)
figures out *why* all of this should exist, the technology choices
will follow. Debating the technology before determining the purpose
is cart-before-horse. You must know what you want and why before all
else.
\_ You sound like twohey. (just an observation)
\_ twohey was the ONLY dissenting vote in 2001 when a vote of
dissolution was put to a meeting of politburo. You can thank
him for the csua even existing. -!//e
\_ I don't see this reflected in the minutes. Explain? --toulouse
\_ It was kept out of the minutes. We had quorum, 3 officers
2 voted for dissolution, //e abstained. Needed all 3 for
it to pass.
\_ Contrary to appearances, the purpose of the CSUA has been hotly
debated as of late, typically during Politburo meetings, with the
participation of active CSUA members. You are sending an important
message to nobody that you really need to reach, but the good news is
that they've already been thinking about it. MOTD is already
acknowledged to be totally useless to the current CSUA membership,
and is maintained (IMO) as legacy out of consideration for alumni.
In fact, soda is used a lotby alumni, as well. I think the point
is that the debate below is trying to figure out what crusties will
bitch and moan about least, because engaging with alumni is seen as
A Good Thing(tm). P.S. if you're going to try to prescribe what you
think the CSUA should do, please don't be an anonymous coward; sign
your post. --toulouse
\_ much respect bro, but the point of motd is to have an anon forum
it lets 1. people whistleblow and 2. gets around petty csua
politics/internal squabbling.
\_ My advice is generic for any situation. I'm not sure why it
matters who I am. I'm happy to hear that this is already being
discussed at the Politburo. I do wonder why it matters what a
few alumni think if they're not coming into contact with the
undergrads as it sounds. Maybe there's some other place where
alums and ugrads are interacting I don't know about.
--!twohey, alum
\_ This leads to the meta-question of is there any value in maintaining
contact between the undergrads and the alumni? If so, how do we
connect?
\_ Yes it's valuable but not in the way it's currently done. Find
a new forum other than MOTD that's more effective (like FB or
LinkedIn). Establish some online service for job seekers and
advertisers to find each other. Start something like a project
or company or whatever. Otherwise, CSUA is nothing more than
an organization with regular meetings and a Linux server.
\_ The csua is good for playing video games.
\_ Do they still have that giant tv screen with that game where
you only fight bosses? It was neat.
\_ as an undergrad, I think the csua should have more FREE FOOD and
more video games and give me internships with sexy companies like
google or microsoft
\_ so this is what a "society in decline" feels like. |