1/27 http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090127/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_gaza_challenged_8
In one classroom Saturday, when UNRWA schools reopened, a Palestinian
teacher was filmed asking children about their trauma during the war.
The unidentified teacher then told the children that Palestinians have
to "wage war against them (Israelis) until they leave their land," and
asked her students, aged about 8, how they should react.
Two children in the class suggested hurling stones or rockets back at
Israel. "Okay," the teacher said, apparently summing up her class'
position. "We throw rockets at them, we throw stones at them," she
said.
\_ Yawn
\_ Yes, the appropriate response to invasion by foreigners is
surrender! How dare they defend themselves?
\_ Would you like freedom fries with that?
\_ I wouldn't ever advise kids to throw rocks at an army. Maybe the
teacher should be throwing rocks at Hamas (their elected gov't).
\_ right! we got rid of our moron leader Bush.. they should
do the same or stfu
\_ Who is the foreigner? The land belongs to both. However, only
one side is willing to accept the presence of the other.
\_ Complete bullshit. c.f. "right of return". Also, there are
Israelis who don't accept the presence of the Arabs. Clearly
the Palestinians have by far the worse situation, they have
the worst land, are poor, and live under a sort of Israeli
lockdown. So it's not really surprising that Israel is more
accepting of this situation.
But this is how peace always works. It takes one side or the
other to basically give up. But this only works when there is
a viable alternative path, like Germany and Japan after WWII
were pretty fucked, especially Germany, but there was an
economic path to prosperity. The Palestinians' situation is
being in disjointed non-nation territories with various
instances of Israeli settlement and security checkpoints etc.
\_ Israel has a rather large Palestinian population (20%) and
Palestinians are represented in the Knesset. There is
no reason why the Palestinians cannot live in Israel.
As for 'right of return' they mostly left on their own
accord fearing that Israelis would be as barbaric as they
are and most of them don't want back. They want their
own State, which they already fought for and lost.
\_ Isreal will not let them back, that is why they
cannot live in Israel. Some left in 48, some were
forcibly moved and most were born since then.
\_ If they were born since then how can they "go back"?
Can Americans go back to England? Can Mexicans
go back to Spain? They are being ridiculous.
\_ How could the Jews "go back" to "their" holy land.
\_ Thank the Brits.
\_ Germans can "go back" to Germany, even the ones
born two generations after their grandparents
were shipped by Stalin to the Urals. Many other
countries use Jus sanguinis (nationality by
blood) rather than Jus soli (nationality by
place of birth) even the US, to a certain
extent.
\_ can I say Israel is a "racist" nation just because by definition
it is a "Jewish" state? It is well known that Palestinians in
Israel doesn't have the same right as regular Jews. |