11/19 Steve Levy >> Joe Ayoob
Its funny how Tedford put him in for like two plays at the very end of
the game (when we were up by 24 points with like 30 seconds to go).
-mrauser
\_ Levy really didn't throw very well, and the offense didn't
move very well until the game was in hand. I'll give him
kudos for winning his first collegiate start, but I haven't
seen anything to indicate he's better than Ayoob. (Ayoob has
six wins). -tom
\_ Levy just doesn't have the brain freeze that Ayoob does.
Ayoob kills the team with mistakes.
\_ Levy fumbled deep in our own end with the score 6-3.
He also threw an interception when we were in field goal
range when the score was 13-3. -tom
\_ And yet still made far fewer mistakes than Ayoob has
been making.
\_ His mistakes didn't happen to cost us, playing against
a weak team. Ayoob had five victories in a row over
weak teams. I don't think Ayoob is great, but Levy
is not a real QB, and if we go into a bowl game with
him at QB, any decent defense will put a spy on him
and he will be in trouble. -tom
\_ You are right that Levy is not a 'real QB'. I
think he sucks. Yet, I'd still rather have him
out there over Ayoob. Only one turnover in the
entire game. Levy tries to do less than Ayoob
and that helps the team more.
\_ Ayoob has had one or fewer turnovers five times
this year. -tom
\_ And 7 INTs in 2 games, which sent him to
the bench.
\_ He threw four INTs in the USC game. One
was when he and the receiver didn't
agree on the route (if Jackson had turned
the route up, it would not have been
intercepted). One hit the receiver in
both hands, but went through his hands.
One was a desperation play at the end
of the half, and the other was on fourth
down. It's not clear that *any* of them
constituted a mistake on Ayoob's part. -tom
\_ You've got to be kidding me. Let me
guess: Ayoob is your cousin or something.
\_ let me guess; you don't understand
the difference between a decision
and a result. -tom
\_ Ayoob's decision-making is terrible.
\_ It's at least as good as Levy's.
-tom
\_ Based on what?
\_ Based on knowing a lot
about football, having
season tickets, and
watching the two of
them all year. -tom
\_ If you're defending
Ayoob then I have
to question your
credentials as
someone who 'knows a
lot about football'.
His play is
inexcusably terrible.
\_ His play has not
been good, but he
won six games.
Levy against
Stanford never
went past his
first read, and
had serious happy
feet in the second
half. 8 of his
10 completions
were dumpoffs or
short outs, and
he telegraphed
every pass. Even
the TD pass to
Jackson was badly
underthrown,
although I wouldn't
exactly call that
a mistake since
it was a good
matchup for us
in one on one
coverage. -tom
\_ What about the fumble in the USC game?
And don't even get me started on the
OSU game. He should have been pulled
after that fiasco. |