12/02 I have only used Mac laptop (powerbook). However, I am not making
lots of money these days and mac laptops are just too expensive.
To those who have used both Mac and PC laptop, are there cheaper,
faster PC laptops that are no less reliable than the powerbooks?
Are there going to be features that I will miss if I switch, like
target disk mode, etc?
\_ Why don't you post your username. Maybe someone at Apple could
get you a discount.
\_ In my experience (have owned several Mac and PC laptops - have a
G4 powerbook and a Dell now) they are both about as reliable,
which is not very. I've had Sony, IBM, Toshiba, and Dell and
four Macs in the last 7-8 years and they all had problems
in a few years. Heck, the 17" PB went back within the first
month I got it (dead motherboard). Apple said they had a lot of
them back for bad screens, too.
\_ I've owned several PC laptops. I most likely won't buy a Sony
due to bad support. IBM is selling their PC line. Dell is
relatively reliable and all repairs are done onsite if under
warranty (yes they come to your house even to replace a faulty
keyboard). If IBM weren't selling off their division I would
recommend them, however who knows what this will do to their
support.
\_ Got a link to the announcement? This is very interesting.
\_ http://tinyurl.com/6rgdw . I like mine, but be careful
as ThinkPad BIOS tend to be a bit weird in some respects--
they're great for Windows, but I've run into tremendous
problems getting a real OS to run on one (primarily things
like ACPI, their non-keyboard buttons, etc. tend to make
your life difficult.) -John
\_ Eh, you just don't know how to recompile the kernel
properly. Anyway, I wouldn't call Linux or FleaBSD
a "real OS". If they were a "real OS" you wouldn't
have to fuck around with them as much.
\_ I'm sorry, did you have anything of substance to
contribute? I take it you've an X series handy on
which you've done this yourself? No? Oh, and NDIS
is great for wireless scanning? What's that I hear?
No? Oh my bad! I suppose you'll be keeping your
cakehole shut then. Go back to troll school. -John
\_ not above poster, but i've installed FC3 on my
wife's x40 and have ACPI suspend to ram and
hibernate working using the hotkeys. wireless
a/b/g works, but there does seem to be some
wonkiness w/ X resuming from hibernate on
occasion.
\_ What's a real os?
\_ Anything w/ DX9, how can it be a real OS if you
can't play HL2 on it?
\_ You can have a base iBook for $999+tax
\_ A decent PC laptop will cost you about $1K (probably
more). Don't go for the $500-$700 ones b/c you will
probably end up with a lemon. Everyone I know who
bought one of the cheap dells or hps has had to send
it in for a repair w/in the first 6 mo.
The best PC laptop was probably a IBM ThinkPad, but
IBM is selling thier PC business, so it might be risky
to by a ThinkPad at this point in time. Also ThinkPads
sometimes had problems running Linux/FreeBSD (not sure
if you care about this).
If you really want to look at a PC laptop, try Fujitsu.
The LifeBook series is pretty good, and the ToughBook
series is super rugged.
Unless you have a specific reason for wanting a PB,
why don't you consider an iBook. It is light, durable,
has good battery life and is pretty cheap. If you are
willing to go refurb you can get a 1ghz model for around
$800, with tax, ae and extra ram you are looking at about
$1K (about the same price as a okay PC laptop). I know
some people complain that there is no PCMCIA slot and
that the screen is only 12" 1024x768, but I switched from
a PB to a 12" iBook last year (for coding and non coding
homework) and I haven't had any problems. In fact I like
my iBook more than my PB b/c it is lighter, has better
wireless reception and has much longer battery life. |