2/13 I'm a cable modem user (comcast). More and more ISPs have been
blocking email sent from my home server for being a cable modem
user. Has this been happening to DSL users, too? Just now earthlink
bounced me for being a "dynamic ip/openrelay" as if it is the same
thing. I don't care about the various cable vs. dsl flame fests. I
just need to know if switching to DSL will help or not. thanks!
\_ I'm on dsl but havben't noticed it yet because I dont care to mail
to folks on those systems. I feel earthlink's pain though, with
the millions of hax0red windows boxes out on the net on dsl and cable
that are just one giant spam sending farm.
\_ I understand why they do it but they don't provide anyway to get
on an exceptions list, nor do they monitor and block the problem
hosts. It's the one-axe-fits-all nature of their solution that
bothers me. Anyway, I'm screwed and there's nothing I can do
about it in that sense. I need to find another answer for
hosting my email.
\_ How would they make exception for a DYNAMIC ip address?
\_ My IP is DHCP assigned but then sticks around forever.
I also have a hostname which has never changed. The
only time my IP has changed is when they sell the
company.
\_ Comcast's use policy forbids running a server on their network.
\_ Comcast's use policy fprbids running a server on their network.
Generally, DSL is a better system for servers. They offer static
IP addresses, and they allow servers. In general, the phone
company is better for this type of thing because they are setup
to serve both residential and businesses customers. The cable
company is primarity a residential consumer service.
http://www.comcast.net/terms/use.jsp
\_ Comcast purchased a company which purchased the company with
whom I had an AUP that did not forbid servers. I've never
signed anything else since then so they are legally required
to uphold that earlier contract. Anyway, that isn't my
problem. Comcast isn't screwing me at all. It's more and
more other ISPs that are blocking mail from my Comcast
provided net. Comcast has actually provided me really great
service and I wouldn't think of leaving them if other ISPs
weren't blocking. I was also thinking of getting hosted at
some colocation facility. That should give me static IP,
lots of quality net and get entirely off the residential
services for my email. If anyone has experience with that
I'd like to hear about it. Thanks!
\_ have you checked your original Terms of Conditions.. etc...
to see if they reserved the right to change these conditions
with prior notice? It's pretty standard that they include
such a clause which lets them change their policy by giving
you warning so that you can cancel your service if you don't
like the change.
\_ I was never given notice of changes. Anyway, it's the kind
of thing which only exists in theory anyway, since me nor
anyone else is going to sue to enforce a $50/month
contract. Anyway, the very concept is ridiculous because
a default OS install comes with numerous servers already
running. If they shut off anyone who runs a server, their
entire customer base would go.
\_ its usually a slip enclosed in a bill that you will
end up throwing away without noticing
\_ 5 weeks ago, I got a "viper" dedicated debian server at
rackforce. best I could find. It's been great so far.
\_ Thanks, I'll check it out.
\_ Please define what a server is. It's harder than you think.
Chances are, clauses in AUP's that broadly ban ``servers''
are not enforcable.
\_ please read the AUP URL before making a comment like that.
\_ Why bother? I don't subscribe to Comcast, so the matter
is academic to me.
\_ try sending the email through comcast's mail server.
\_ A simple way to do this automagically without reconfiguring
your mail clients and still keeping control of your mail server
for incoming mail is to set your mail server to use Comcast's
mail server as a smarthost. This is trivial to do in all
major mail servers. -dans
\_ I had considered using them as a smarthost but I've read so
much about how crummy the servers are, mail getting dropped
without notice, etc, that I'd be happier if there was some
other service I could switch to that simply isn't getting
blocked by other ISPs yet still run my own mail server.
\_ I run a mail server that doesn't suck. As long as you
are not using your mail server for hosing, I'd be glad
to act as primary or secondary MX for you. Email me
and we'll see if we can work something out. -dans
\_ I'd like to thank everyone who posted for the quality replies. I
didn't hold out much hope posting on Saturday morning. Once again,
the motd comes through. --op
to serve both residential and businesses customers. The cable
company is primarity a residential consumer product.
I'd like to hear about it. Thanks!
\_ I have comcast cable service for access and "viper"
dedicated debian server at rackforce. It is great.
\_ Two months ago, I got a "viper" dedicated debian server at
rackforce. best I could find. great so far. -brett
\_ Don't get too spoiled. |